IGEL Conference 2000, Toronto
Abstracts
IGEL: The Idea Behind the Organization
Siegfried J. Schmidt
When, in 1987, the members of the research group NIKOL (Achim Barsch, Peter Hejl,
Gebhard Rusch, Siegfried J. Schmidt, and Reinhold Viehoff) decided to establish an international
society for empirical research in literature, the idea behind this decision was very clear; to give new
theoretical approach an institutionalized form in order to increase the chances of being recognized
and acknowledged in the traditional world of literary studies. Perhaps all scientific societies have
been established for this purpose. The case of IGEL was slightly different in so far as empirical
studies in literature can only be performed in an interdisciplinary way. As a consequence, the future
member of IGEL had to be looked for in many disciplines from anthropology to sociology and
psychology. Interdisciplinary studies demand continuous and international communication and
exchange of ideas, methodological developments and research results in order to make further
progress. Accordingly, the foundation of IGEL resulted as well from scientific political as from
scientific considerations.
What has happened to these basic ideas of the founding fathers? As far as I can see the
scientific goals have been partially reached. There exists an IGEL-community which successfully
tries to increase interaction and cooperation on an international level, despite the fact that
especially in complex and demanding research endeavors a lot of fundamental questions have to
be tackled and divergences are foreseeable and normal (let me just mention the debate on
constructivism or systems theory).
Regarding the scientific political goals, IGEL has been less successful. Empirical studies
still belong to the family of minor approaches as compared to the big clan of interpretation freaks.
Nevertheless, some of typical IGEL-ideas have intruded into the mainstream of literary studies, e.g.
the idea of literature as an as well social as symbol system. In sum, the empirical approach is widely
recognized even in recent handbooks and encyclopedias as an interesting approach which can no
longer be overlooked.
In the 90's, IGEL has concentrated a lot of attention to other media since it became clear that
literature can only be observed and analyzed as a specific medium in difference to other media.
Accordingly, literary studies were modeled as a specific kind of media studies or studies in media
culture, respectively. My personal idea is that media-orientation should be continued, and that IGEL
should have an eager eye on what happens to literature and to literary studies in the times of
Internet.
- 1. Invited Address
SEMIOSIS AND AESTHESIS: FROM SIGNS TO
DE-SIGNS IN ARTISTIC EXPRESSION
Marcel Danesi
This talk will look at the conundrum of art (focusing on the music of Beethoven) from the
standpoint of classical semiotic theory. It will propose that great art, like bodily symptomatology
(semiosis), emanates from and affects the body and the emotional system in virtually the same way
that "disease" does. This would explain why many artists have been portrayed as "diseased"
(literally "not at ease corporeally") and it would tie the physiological-aesthetic experience to the
spiritual aesthetic experience. Starting from Plato to Langer, several key theories of aesthetics will
be examined in this light. But its main focus will be on the view of the Italian philosopher
Giambattistica Vico (1688-1744) who saw art as the expression of the human "ingegno". This
paper is, in a fundamental sense, an exploration of "ingenious" sign-making as it manifests itself in
the most inexplicable domain of experience of all--art.
3. Workshop
METAPHOR IDENTIFICATION AND ANALYSIS,
RECOGNITION AND PROCESSING
Raymond Gibbs and Gerard Steen
This two-part workshop is intended to demonstrate some aspects of metaphor identification
and analysis in relation to research on metaphor recognition and processing.
In our theoretical presentation, we shall clarify our view of the technique of metaphor
identification and analysis in discourse with reference to the work done by a special interest group
in metaphor in the Poetics And Linguistics Association run by Gerard Steen. This work is based on
a cognitive approach to metaphor which also facilitates a connection with psychological research on
metaphor recognition and processing. There is a particularly interesting bridging function for the
use of propositional analysis as used in discourse psychology here. Ray Gibbs will address the
wider psychological and cultural backgrounds of such a cognitive approach to metaphor in
language use.
The workshop will then go on to have a look at some metaphors in literary texts and address
the question of the reliability of their identification and analysis. In the workshop we will also
discuss possibilities for doing research on the recognition and processing of these metaphors by
readers of literature.
4. Paper Session
PSYCHODYNAMIC PROCESSES
Perception of Women in Literature and Author Pathology
Anne Martindale
This presentation will describe computer content analytic studies of author pathology based
on Jung's anima archetype. Theoretically, the anima (representation of feminine qualities in a man)
of an author would be projected onto romantic heroines and would reflect the man's psychological
development. Biographical surveys produced samples of short story authors with and without
evidence of psychological disturbance. Each author was represented by one romantic short story
that included a hero, heroine, and control male and female characters.
Analyses were done on a validation sample of works cited by Jungians and on thirty short
stories classified by author pathology. A number of content analytic measures were used, including
a dictionary designed to measure anima qualities and the Regressive Imagery Dictionary.
Validation and research studies demonstrated that authors use more primary process words
in descriptions of female characters and in describing the hero/anima characters compared to the
control characters. Although the overall anima measure did not produce significant results based on
author pathology, an interesting pattern emerged from tags that did reach significance. For
example, both validation and research studies found that romantic heroines were associated with
negative animals and negation words. Authors show a tendency to use a passive style, describing
anima characters by association and by saying what they are not, rather than what they are.
Compared to normal authors, abnormal authors seem to show increased ambivalence. Abnormal
authors use more terms of endearment in stories, combined with increased use of words connoting
evil and control. Although they do not describe male characters as weak, the abnormal authors
place male characters in relation to stronger others, indirectly implying weakness.
This paper focuses on the use of computer content analytic results indicating that authors
with evidence of pathology adopt a more passive writing style reflective of increased ambivalence
regarding romantic themes.
Family Background and Motivation for Literary Creativity
Albert Rothenberg
Objective: To identify family background and developmental factors involved in motivation
for high achievement creativity in literature. Method: Biographical information regarding parental
background was collected for all (48) Nobel Laureates in Literature for whom English language
sources were available. Results: None of the parents of the subjects were in same profession as
their offspring in contrast to Galton's classic genetically focused findings of a high degree of
association between "genius" and parental skill and eminence. Also, according to U.S. Bureau of
Census data, approximately 23% of the general male population follow the same occupations as
their fathers.
However, a specific type of family background pattern was identified in the Nobel Laureate
Group. In 66% of cases, same-sexed parents had followed a performance related occupation such
as journalism, acting, law, and ministry, or opposite sexed parents had actively engaged in literary or
artistic pursuits. Of the same-sexed parents in related performance occupations, half were implicitly
or explicitly interested in literature, writing, or the serious pursuit of creative work. In unrelated
occupations, an additional 25% of the same-sexed parents harbored lifelong wishes to write or were
enamoured with storytelling, inventiveness, or written diaries, or else engaged in other literary
activities. Conclusion: Upbringing within this overall pattern of family structure induces intense
motivation for literary creativity because the offspring both identify and compete with the
same-sexed parents' unrealized creative goals. They are driven to live out the same-sexed parents'
fantasies as well as supersede them by outstanding accomplishment in a creative field. Separate
ongoing investigations of outstanding creative people in science and in other artistic fields reveal a
similar family background pattern in these groups. Developmental relationships between the
motivational factor and the structure of creative cognition will be discussed.
A Comparative Study of Literary and Freudian Text Processing
Laszlo Halasz
Even at the beginning of his psychoanalytical work, Freud realized, rather ambivalently, that
some of his texts could be read as short stories. Since then, several excellent writers have rated
Freud highly as an author of full literary value. No doubt, while some of Freud's works strive to
build on contradiction-free abstract conceptual-logical thinking, to grasp universal rules, trends, and
mechanisms, others are much closer to literary fictions, creating an interesting and vividly dramatic
story by portraying individual situations and events. An appreciation of differences between literary
and Freudian text processing can be achieved by comparing Freudian texts with other fictive and
nonfictive texts.
In this paper, four short text extracts on the theme of death were chosen which were
meaningful and easily understandable. The materials included: a literary narrative fiction from
Waterland by Graham Swift; an autobiographical narrative as a transition between fiction and
nonfiction from Freud's letter to Fliess; a narrative nonfictive report from The Independent by P.
Davison, and a scientific-expository text from Mourning and Melancholy by S. Freud.
Fifty motivated secondary school students before their matriculation examinations (average
age 17.5 and equally divided between males and females) took part in the study. They read
thoroughly all the unfamiliar texts one after another. Following the reading of a text, questionnaires
specified the subject's tasks: to judge the text on a six-item semantic differential (complex-simple,
meaningless-meaningful etc.); to give three key words which together expressed the meaning of the
text as optimally as possible; to underline the affects which the subject felt during reading from a
twelve-item list (I was happy, it bored me etc.); to enumerate the affects which the protagonist
experienced. Finally, after rereading all the texts, subjects categorized each of them into one of the
textual type ("genre") as follows: report, autobiographical document, literary narrative, transition
between them, something else. The order of the texts, the questionnaires, and even the items, were
randomized, except the last questionnaire in which only the order of items was randomized. The
results for the texts are presented and discussed from the point of view of each of the most relevant
variables.
5. READING PROCESSES: I
Involvement, Distance, and Appreciation for Fictional Characters
Elly Konijn & Johan Hoorn
In perceiving and experiencing fictional characters (PEFiC), readers of literature and
spectators of theater, art, film, TV, and other media establish affective relationships with persons
they have never met or who do not even exist. The concepts of identification and empathy
supposedly account for this phenomenon, although they are theoretically blurry, measurement is
problematic, and empirical findings are inconsistent. The PEFiC model is context and situation
dependent and explains when and how subjects get involved with dramatis personae in terms of
(dis)similarity, relevance, valence, and ethic (good-bad), aesthetic (beautiful-ugly), and
epistemological (realistic-unrealistic) appraisals. Features of a character can be experienced
simultaneously as positive and negative (e.g., good and ugly). Therefore, involvement and distance
are considered parallel processes, the trade-off between which determines the appreciation for the
character.
"Reading to Mom" - A Literary Reading Experience Inside a Matriarchal Family
Andrea Claudia F. Valente
This paper is part of an ongoing dissertation about a case study on pedagogical reading
practice of an in-service novice teacher at CLAC - Cursos de Línguas Abertos à Comunidade -
(language courses open to the community in Rio de Janeiro) at Universidade Federal do Rio de
Janeiro (UFRJ). She teaches a course in English as a Foreign Language to develop reading skills in
a specific group of undergraduate students at the same university. In brief, this dissertation applies
an ethnographic research which is divided into two contexts: The first concerns an informal
environment where literary reading occurs; the second refers to a formal one where non-literary
reading happens.
In this work, I propose to investigate the teacher's behaviour and reading habits in the
informal environment, or rather, inside her family context. The research theory is founded in the
Empirical Study of Literature (Schmidt, 1980) and in its correlative authors. It is based on a
qualitative methodology which uses the following tools: 1-recorded (informal) interviews between
the researcher and the teacher about her life story (biography); 2- recorded reading aloud of literary
texts by the teacher to her family; 3- recorded discussion of the texts between her and the family;
and; 4- recorded interviews between the researcher and the teacher on the reading events which were
previously recorded by the teacher.
The data from the interviews on biography are analyzed by a specific method:
contextualised stylistics (Zyngier,1994) based on a transitivity system (Halliday, 1985). The rest of
the data are analysed under certain pragmatic frames and cognition dimensions of literary reading
(Vipond & Hunt, 1984) so as to evaluate participants' dialogic involvement.
Modernism and Modernity: The Reversibility of Perspective
Garry Leonard
"Modernism" has long been considered an aesthetic movement that made possible the
representation of modernity. In his famous review of Joyce's Ulysses, T.S. Eliot hailed Joyce's
revolutionary stylistics, declaring them nothing less than "a step toward making the modern world
possible for art." But, looked at in a historical context, "modernism" is a much more jumbled
reaction to rather than a comprehensive representation of it. Indeed, how could this be otherwise
when a salient feature of modernity is a crisis in faith concerning the possibility of mimetic
representation? The paradox modernism attempts to resolve is how to represent the illusion of
representation. Cubism, Surrealism, Futurism, all these sub-sets of modernism, frame the reality of
modernity, even as they break this same frame in order to draw attention to it, so as to reveal the
artifice it imposes in order to constitute the apparently real. This imposition, in turn, composes a
"reality" we, as observers, conspire to make credible through interpretation.
These interpretations then help further create the very notion of modernity that is presumed
to be the unmediated reality stimulating aesthetic experimentation. In other words, the aesthetic
strategies of modernism and the historical contingencies of modernity are mutually constitutive and
involve what the French philosopher Merleau-Ponty calls the "reversibility of perspectives." The art
we create allows us to see both the "reality" pre-figured after the work of art and the "reality" we
presume pre-exists it. In other words, the art we see, also "sees" us, in the sense it shapes not only
what we have not known how to see, but also what we belive artists saw previously when they
formulated their aesthetic approach. "Seeing" really is "believing"-- and they're not the same thing
at all. Or, as Wallace Stevens put it, "it is the belief, and not the God, that matters."
6. Symposium
INTERCULTURAL PERSPECTIVES ON THE RECEPTION OF LITERATURE
Jèmeljan Hakemulder
Literature in a Multicultural Society
Jèmeljan Hakemulder
This paper reports on a research program concerning the role of cultural canons in the
Dutch, multicultural society. In one of the projects of this national program the effects of reading
literature on social perception was examined. Does it affect who we consider to be part of our
ingroup and who we would like to exclude from that group? Does it affect moral judgments about
people with a different set of norms and values than ours? Theorists often assume that literature
does influences the perception of our fellow human beings. They suggest literature might bridge the
gap between ethnic/social groups: reading stories about each other would make readers realize that,
essentially, all people have the same goals in life, the same fears, and the same human weaknesses.
With this understanding, feelings of solidarity would also be enhanced. Furthermore, reading
literature would stimulate readers' empathic abilities and thus make it easier to imagine, for instance,
what it must be like to be someone who has grown up in an entirely different culture than theirs.
This might result in a better appreciation of cultural differences. A number of experiments were
conducted to determine whether these effects do occur and which aspect of the reading experience
may be responsible.
The Impact of Discussing vs. Reading Literary Texts
Willie van Peer & Aikaterini Nousi
Hakemulder (1999), on the basis of an extensive review of the literature, comes to the
conclusion that reading literature may sometimes have an effect on attitudes, especially those related
to sex roles and to outsiders. It remains unclear in most of these studies, however, whether the
observed effects are due to the reading itself or to the subsequent treatment of the texts in group
discussion, since the design of most experiments does not make it possible to disentangle these
effects. To do so is the central aim of the present paper. Participants in the experiment were 80
non-German readers (55 female, 25 male) with relatively high linguistic proficiency, who informed
the experimenters on their attitudes toward Germans and German society. To investigate the relative
contribution of either reading or discussing literary texts, readers in one experimental group read
two texts and filled out a battery of items aimed to capture the influence of the reading on their
prejudices. A second experimental group read the same texts, but on top of their reading discussed
these texts in group during two sessions of 90 minutes each. A control group was involved in
neither reading nor discussion. All three groups were presented with a pre- and post- tests designed
to capture their attitudes toward a non-native, i.e. German, culture. Comparison of the results makes
it possible to determine the influence of reading and discussion on readers' attitudes.
The Reception of a Turkish Literary Text by Turkish-Dutch and Dutch Pupils
Dick Schram and Cor Geljon
An increasing number of students in secondary education do not have an originally Dutch
background. At the same time, the Dutch literature teaching programme makes it possible to
integrate texts of nonwestern literatures into the literature lesson. These two facts prompted us to
explore the reception process of - in this case - Turkish-Dutch and Dutch pupils, in order to see
whether we can adjust the methodology accordingly. The text is a Turkish short story in translation;
reception concerns not only meaning attribution and evaluation but also the cognitive strategies in
the ongoing process of understanding in a thinking out-loud experiment.
7. Invited Address
WRITING AS THINKING READING AS FEELING
Keith Oatley
In order to investigate the psychology of literature, we need to cast the questions into
psychological form. Writing has traditionally been considered as a mode of communication, and it
is. I extend this analysis by showing how the technology of writing (pen and paper, typewriter and
scissors, word processor) have also allowed it to become a distinctive form of thinking. Thinking is
an activity we know something about, and I will show how writing enables thinking in ways that
would be difficult or impossible without technologies that allow externalization in semi-permanent
form of the products of mind. I will discuss psychological studies of expertise, and show how
Shakespeare and Jane Austen were assisted by the technology of writing and paper. Reading has
traditionally been seen as the reception of communication. I extend this analysis by showing that a
principal effect of reading of fiction is the experience of emotions, as the reader not only receives a
communication, but uses its clues to construct the particular version of the story that he or she
experiences. I describe empirical studies in which emotionsat the time of reading and as recalled
in autobiographical memoriesbecome part of the constructions that the reader makes. Of course,
writing is not just thinking, nor reading just feeling. There is a strong emotional component in the
writing of fiction, without which fiction would be lifeless. I shall exemplify this in the writing of
Virginia Woolf. There is a strong thinking component in reading, without which reading would be
inert. I shall illustrate this by reference to Dante and Barthes. Not only are writing and reading
products of both thinking and feeling, they are also ways in which we can begin to change the
implicit theories in which we are lodged.
8. Paper Session
READING PROCESSES: II
Who Wants What in a Story: The Effects of Reader's Impressions of the Characters
Scotty Craig, Arthur Graesser & Mary Cregger
One of our oldest forms of media is written text. It is not surprising that the area of text
comprehension has shown several representations of how people interact with text. Gernsbacher,
Goldsmith and Robertson (1992) claim that, as we read, we develop elaborate lifelike mental
representations of what we are reading and, furthermore, readers form explicit lifelike mental
representations of fictional character's emotional states that are often implicit. Also, these implicit
emotional states in a story world are needed for discourse understanding for a story (Gernsbacher,
1994). Similarly, Graesser and colleagues (1996, 1999) tested reader's beliefs of who knows what
in a story. They found that participants had no trouble reconstructing who knows what in a story.
In the present study, we investigated the factors that predict a reader's beliefs about who wants what
in a story. Participants read one of 10 stories and were then asked to rate how much each of the
characters would want an event from the story to occur.
The two factors we investigated were reader's ratings of whether they liked the character
(liked or disliked) and if their judgement of the type of person that the character was (good or bad).
Both of these were rated on a scale of 1 to 6. One was the extreme positive rating (I liked this
character a lot; I would judge this character to be an extremely good person) and 6 was the extreme
negative rating (I disliked this character a lot; I would judge this character to be an extremely bad
person). A preliminary analysis of the data has been conducted. Judgment of the character did not
seem to matter for their wants. However, the reader's liking of the character did seem to be a
significant predictor.
Narratorial Relevance and Character Goals
Peter Dixon & Marisa Bortolussi
In narratology and discourse processing, it is common to describe the structure of events in
the story world independently of the manner of narration and the perspective of the narrator. In
contrast, we argue that readers generally process the narrative as if they were communicating with
the narrator. As a consequence, they represent only those aspects of the story world that are relevant
to the point or message the narrator seems to intend. For example, it is usually assumed that readers
track the goal structure of characters so that they can interpret characters' plans and understand
motivations for their actions. However, we hypothesize that characters' goals are represented only
to the extent that the narrator appears to signal that such goals are relevant to his or her
communicative purpose. In order to test this hypothesis, we developed passages in which two
characters share a superordinate goal (e.g., taking a fishing trip) that can be accomplished if both
characters succeed in their respective sub-goals (e.g., getting a fishing license and renting a boat).
Sentence reading time was measured as a function of the relationship between the sub-goals and the
manner in which the passage was introduced by the narrator. When the narrator emphasized the
relevance of the superordinate goal, readers took additional time to coordinate information from the
two sub-goals when they both succeeded. However, when the narrator emphasized only the
relevance of one of the sub-goals, no such effect was found. This result suggests that readers'
representation of goal structures is mediated by their representation of the narrator and his or her
apparent communicative intent. In general, this study supports the view that readers represent goals,
make inferences, and generate expectations primarily in service of understanding the narrator as a
conversational participant.
Thematic Processing of Narrative Text
Shannon Whitten & Arthur Graesser
The goal of this study was to determine how global, thematic information is accessed in the
process of narrative comprehension. To investigate this, story pairs with the same thematic
structures were created. The thematic Story A was accompanied by an explicit adage, such as, "All
that glitters is not gold." Story B was subsequently presented with the same theme, but without
explicitly stating the adage. This story activated the global message and associated adage in the first
story. Following Story B, participants performed a word recognition task in which the probe word
was a word from the adage in the first story (e.g., 'glitter'). This word was not relevant to the event
structure of Story B. Therefore, the effect was due to the activation of the global theme and adage.
These results were compared to a control condition, where Stories A and B had no thematic
similarity. This condition controlled for possible lexical activation by introducing the same prose in
word from the thematic condition.
The results of two experiments indicate that thematic activation is spontaneous. The first
experiment demonstrated a significant difference in response times to the probe when participants
engaged in deliberative processing. Experiment 2 attempted to encourage deliberative processing
and found an overall significant effect for response times. Furthermore, participant ratings of the
similarity between each story and the adage were collected in a separate study. When deliberative
processing was not encouraged, the similarity ratings for Story B were significantly correlated with
standardized response times. However, when deliberative processing was encouraged, similarity
ratings for Story A were significantly correlated with standardized response times. These results
show that thematic activation depends on the storage and retrieval conditions.
Experi/Mental Models, or How We Learn From Literary Fictions
Peter Swirski
We all agree that literary fictions offer a wealth of knowledge which awaits to be tapped. Yet
most aspects of this crucial consensus have up to now remained largely uninvestigated. A virtual
absence of research into how we learn from literary fictions has also significantly impoverished an
inquiry into what we may learn from them. My objective in this presentation is to provide a detailed
account of a possible avenue of research into the relation between the mode of cognition typical to
literary fictions and the type of research common in philosophy. Placing fictions on the level of
thought experiments, a well-established and increasingly well-understood instrument of learning,
will allow me to define, analyze, and propose solutions to several problems in literary epistemology.
Among them are two of the central conundra of dealing with fictions in a cognitive context: How is
it that literary fictions can offer real-world (i.e. nonfictional) knowledge? What are the mechanisms
behind this type of epistemic transfer? Among broader disciplinary goals, such research is
designed to help establish a progressive epistemological base for literary studies as a full-fledged
research (as opposed to critical reading oriented) discipline. Second, it should help extend the
results of research into philosophical thought experiments to a detailed model of literary fictions as
narrative thought experiments.
9. Symposium
CONDITIONS FOR THE EFFECTS OF LITERATURE
Jèmeljan Hakemulder
Becoming What We Behold: A Feeling for Literature
Don Kuiken & David Miall
Feelings during literary reading can be characterized at four levels. First, feelings such as
suspense and amusement are reactions to an already interpreted narrative (Hansson, 1990). While
providing an incentive to sustain reading, these feelings play no significant role in the distinctively
literary aspects of text interpretation. Second, feelings that derive from perceived affinity with an
author, narrator, or narrative figure are the outcome of an interpretive process by which a fictional
representation is developed. Although important in the reader's development of a situation model
(Kneepens & Zwaan, 1994), these feelings, too, do not derive from distinctively literary aspects of
text interpretation. Third, feelings of appreciation (aesthetic pleasure or interest) are an initial
moment in readers' response to the formal components of literary texts (narrative, stylistic, or
generic). Although serving to capture and hold readers' attention (Miall & Kuiken, 1994), these
aesthetic reactions only anticipate the level of feeling that will be the focus of this presentation. This
fourth level of analysis involves the multifaceted and even conflicting tendencies of feeling
(Griffiths, 1997) triggered by the formal components of literary texts. We will argue that (1) the
formal components of literary texts provide composite and interactive metaphors of personal
identification that modify self-understanding (Cohen, 1999); (2) the outcome of textual
re-interpretation at this level is the accentuation of intimacy and intricacy in the reader's experiential
self; (3) the points at which textual re-interpretation exerts this modifying power are those at which
individual differences between readings are most apparent and important; and (4) the familiar
concept of catharsis (the conflict of tragic feelings identified by Aristotle) identifies one particular
form of this more general pattern of response in which feelings evoked during reading modify the
reader: in Coleridge's words, we "become that which we understandly [sic] behold & hear" (1804).
The Trouble with Catharsis
Dolf Zillmann
Involvement with drama is thought capable of relieving aversive emotions. Aristotle said so,
and his suggestion has been a truism ever since. Corroborating colloquial evidence abounds, too.
But oddly, empirical-minded investigators have been utterly frustrated in their attempts at providing
compelling support for cathartic emotion purgation. Why? In hopes of gaining some appreciation
for the dilemma, I shall examine a sampling of research on the emotional consequences of exposure
to drama, to comedy and tragedy in particular, but also to music. Refinements of, and amendments
to, the ancient doctrine will be considered in efforts to make the best of a confused situation.
The Role of Mental Images and Linguistic Coding in
the Comprehension of Narratives
Bob Wyer
People who read a narrative are likely to construct a mental simulation of the events that are
described. This simulation, or "episode model," can have both a linguistic component and a mental
image of the characters and the situation in which they interact. The features of this image are not
necessarily the same as those that are described in the narrative itself. Readers' later memory for the
narrative and perception of its implications may be based on this episode model.
Implications of these possibilities have been examined in a number of studies. One study
demonstrated that when information is conveyed in the form of a narrative, accompanying the
information by pictures facilitates comprehension and, therefore, increases the extremity of
judgments based on it. When the same information is conveyed in a list, however, the pictures
interfere with comprehension. Moreover, asking persons explicitly to imagine the events describe
has much the same effect as actual pictures.
A second study demonstrated that when people are asked to write a narrative description of
the events they have encountered (e.g., those they have seen in a movie), this more abstract verbal
representation can interfere with their memory for the original material. Thus, the comprehension of
written narratives may be facilitated by constructing visual images of the events described. At the
same time, writing a narrative on the basis of observations may be have a detrimental effect on
memory for the visual images that were formed from these observations at the time the observations
were made.
Psychoanalytic Predictions of Reading Behavior
Ingrid Stöger & Willie van Peer
On the basis of Freud's writings, and given some of the further elaborations of later
Freudians, some psychoanalytically oriented predictions were derived concerning the effects of
reading fairy tales on readers. As far as we know, such claims of psychoanalytic critics (which
frequently turn up in the literature) have not been tested empirically. To do so is the central aim of
the current paper. Hypotheses derived from psychoanalytic theory were: Reading particular fairy
tales (1) stimulates the reader to allow repressed feelings of hate against his/her mother; and (2) sets
free and intensifies incestual wishes directed at one's brothers/sisters. Materials used were a fairy
tale from the Grimm collection that answers to the criteria outlined by Freud and his followers to
generate the feelings described in hypotheses (1) and (2). A control test was a rather nonsensical
story about letters in a printer's shop falling in love with each other. The experimental group read
the fairy tale, the control group the control text. Both groups answered a battery of questions aimed
at probing the effects described by the hypotheses. Subjects were 60 students of the University of
Munich, predominantly from the humanities, with an equal distribution across the sexes. Results
allow an independent test of some claims derived from psychoanalysis concerning the reading of
literature.
10. Paper Session
READING PROCESSES: III
Modes of Fiction: Recipients' Views of Fact and Fiction
M. Schreier, N. Groeben, J. Rothmund and I. Nickel-Bacon
In literary studies, the discourse systems of 'fiction' and 'non-fiction' are usually
conceptualised as dichotomous, and media products are assumed to belong to either of the two
categories, but not to both simultaneously. There have always existed media products, however,
which in some regard contradict this distinction (the historical novel, for example); and recently,
new product genres have been gaining in popularity which resist dichotomization even more
strongly (such as docu-soaps or reality TV).
In this paper, we will present a theory of fictionality (and corresponding distinctions
between 'fact' and 'fiction') which transcends previous dichotomies and thus allows for more
differentiated reconstructions of both media products and the reception of these products (cf.
Schreier et al. 1999). In this, we distinguish between three perspectives on fiction and fictionality:
(1) product type (fiction, non-fiction, combination) (2) content (various combinations of (un-)real
and (im)possible types of content and the ways in which these combinations are perceived, and (3)
mode of presentation and reception respectively (more or less close to real-life).
In order to test the validity of this conceptualisation, an extensive interview study (30
participants) was carried out, the first part of the study focusing on media products, the second part
on media reception. For data collection, the semi-structured interview was used in combination with
a number of free sorting tasks. Where media products were concerned, the interviews were
supplemented by the use of a structure formation technique in order to reconstruct participants'
subjective theories on the four main topics of the interview: (1) view of the relation between
mediated and unmediated experience; (2) types of media products; (3) conceptualisation of
'fiction'; and (4) conceptualisation of 'non-fiction'. In addition, a content analysis of the interviews
was carried out. The results of the first part of this study (concerning media products) will be
presented in greater detail.
Tease or Torment? Effects of Teaser and Traditional
Endings in Contemporary Horror Films
Cynthia King
Traditionally, horror films followed classic dramatic formula where "good" ultimately
triumphs over "evil." Following this formula, at the end of the film, the evil is unequivocally
destroyed. Starting in the early 1970's with the success of Rosemary's Baby and The Exorcist, a
new horror formula emerged where the evil/antagonist survives to pave the way for the sequels that
will follow. Typically, these horror films contain teaser endings in which, although at first it may
appear that the evil has been destroyed, a final scene reveals that the evil has survived. Many
popular horror film series such as Halloween, Friday the 13th, and A Nightmare on Elm Street,
contain teaser endings.
Although teaser endings do not appear to be hurting the box office success of these films,
there is no indication how audiences actually feel about this type of ending. Thus, this study seeks
to explore what effect, if any, differences in ending type have on audience perceptions of the films.
Four horror films were manipulated to create versions with traditional endings (endings in
which the evil/antagonist is destroyed) or teaser endings (endings in which the evil/antagonist
revives). Consistent with theories of suspense, viewers who watched the films with traditional
endings found the films more enjoyable. Influences of gender and watcher type were also
examined, although no significant interactions with ending type were found.
The Problem of Rereading for Psychological Theories of Narrative Suspense
William Brewer
In this paper, I examine the ability of a wide range of narrative theories to deal with the
phenomena of narrative rereading. These theories make the following predictions: (1) Uncertainty
theories propose that suspense derives from psychological uncertainty. These theories predict that
on rereading there will be little uncertainty so there will be no suspense and no rereading. (2)
Willing Suspension of Memory
theories postulate that readers ignore information from the first reading so rereading should not
differ from first reading. (3) Shift of Motivation theories argue that the affective states that come
into play on rereading differ from those on first reading and that second readings produce
enjoyment from the literary quality of the text. (4) Theories of Character Identification postulate that
the reader's enjoyment of narrative is derived from the reader's identification with one or more
characters in the narrative. These theories thus predict that there should be no change in reader
affect with rereading.
The problem posed by rereading for these theories can be seen if we assume that most
readers of ordinary entertainment fiction prefer to read a text once, but that some people also choose
to reread a text two or more times. The Willing Suspension of Memory theories, Shift of
Motivation theories, and theories of Character Identification are all consistent with the occurrence
of rereading, but are not consistent with the evidence that most people prefer to read a narrative only
once. The Uncertainty theory predicts single reading, but fails to predict rereading. Thus, none of
the narrative theories is capable of dealing with reader behavior in reading simple entertainment
texts.
In the final section of this paper I will attempt to modify each of these theories to account
for the core reading/rereading phenomena and then evaluate each modified theory.
About the Borderline Between the "Fictitious" and "Real" Reality
R.R. Karagezov & R.G. Kadirova
It is rather significant, although not simple, to answer the question- where is the borderline
between the fictitious and "real" reality? Understanding of this distinction is important at least
because it could provide us with a better idea about general regularities of aesthetic and creative
activities. It would be a mistake to deny the existence of certain relations between these two types of
realities. However, very often we nnot say something essential concerning this relationship.
The human experience undergoes a number of transformations before it will appropriate aesthetic
properties to be expressed by means of art works. As a result, the bond between the author's
individual-biographical experience and the product of his/her aesthetic activity - work of art - slips
one's attention. Therefore it is essential to clarify the psychological processess which are
responsible for this transformation. The answer given in psychoanalysis is not sufficient for a
number of reasons. Thus, the psychoanalytical interpretations which reduce aesthetic activity to the
"games" of unconscious defense mechanisms and are focusing mainly on ties between the work of
art and an author's child experiences fail to explain a broad spectrum of artistic phenomena.
Unlike psychoanalysis which focuses on unconscious aspects of aesthetic activity, we are
more concerned with conscious, "apical" (by Vygotsky's terminology) aspects of this activity.
Based on our studies (R.R. Karakozov,1997) considering artworks as a particular form of
communication of personal sense (A. N. Leontiev), we postulate that aesthetic activity of a subject is
determined by his/her general sense or searching activity, striving to make sense of his/her
biographical life-experience. Developing this postulate we assumed that the process of reflexion is
the central unit of artistic-aesthetic activity of subject. However, it is quite complicated to catch this
invisible reflexive work by analysis because it "evaporates" in the final output-art work. In order to
trace this reflexive activity we need especial methods. Dealing with this, we have elaborated a
special method of diary-keeping activity. The main idea underlying this method is the suggestion
that studying so called "intermediate" forms of aesthetic activity, such as diary keeping activity, can
help us to "catch" the peculiarities of the mind's reflexive activity and to look into the regularities
of aesthetic activity.
11. Paper Session
CULTURAL IDENTITY
Polish and Polish American Representation in Children's Literature Published in the
United States between 1968 and 1998: Exploring Characterizations of and
Ethnicity within Whiteness in Books for Children
James Smolinski
Drawing from Harris's (1993) premise that it is important for children to see their cultures
represented in the books through which they grow literate, this research builds a case study which
reports on and analyzes Polish and Polish American ethnic representation in children's literature
published in the United States between 1968 and 1998--a period that includes Poles being
dominated by Stalinism, the fall of Soviet communism, and the rise of capitalism/democracy in
Poland.
Using semiotic, systems, and content analyses as cornerstones of a qualitative study which
considers over 109 books, this research explores patterns of representation and misrepresentation in
ethnic children's literature. The study continues by comparing children's literature and mainstream
American cultural structures which have historically been used to reduce the significance of the
heritage of Poles. It concludes by offering means through which the publishing industry in the U.S.
might be politically and economically persuaded to generate higher quality children's literature
relating to people of Polish decent in greater numbers.
This empirically based research considers issues of ethnic hegemony and the role of children's
literature in hegemonic cultural production. Taking into account both text and illustrations, this
research explores trends within the literature which arguably constitute foundations of bigotry
against Polonians. In moving towards "multi" in multicultural literature and education to mean
more than categories of race, this research seeks to work against constructed elements of culture
which categorically dominate entire groups.
Imagining Cultural Diversity in the German Media
Elka Tshernokoshewa
Ethnically based cultural diversity is a basic experience of live now in virtually every
European place. This paper asks - how is ethically based cultural diversity discussed in today's
media? What kind of terms are used in this discourse? What kind of figures, metaphors and images
are created thereby? What happens during this process of communication?
This paper is based on an large empirical research of the images of the Sorbs - as a Slavic
minority in Germany - in the German press from 1994 to 1999. Contemporary research of images
of ethnic minorities on the TV are raised too. Examples of significant images are, on the one hand:
"Yesterday is here", "The Sorbs have always been peasants", "Today the Sorbs are responsible for
ancient customs". On the other hand, there are images like: "The Sorbs are champions of survival",
"To grow up with two languages is fun" and "I am both." In my opinion, purity and hybridization
are two vital patterns of thought.
My theoretical argument tries to open ethnological cultural studies to some of the
considerations of system theory and to integrate ethnically-based cultural diversity into
"Differenztheorie". The question of observation and evaluation of differences and hybridization can
be posed as a basic problem in contemporary empirical cultural studies.
The Role of Literature in Constructing and Maintaining Historical Narratives
Janos Laszlo
Earlier studies (Laszlo, 1988, Larsen and Laszlo, 1990) showed that social-historical
knowledge and cultural experience considerably shape interpretation and evaluation of literary texts.
The present study approaches the literature-history link from the opposite angle. Perceptions of the
Hungarian history were studied with a sample of 500 subjects by eliciting narrations on the
country's past. The most significant events of the history and their perceived characteristics were
assessed by content analysis.
A sample of 100 Hungarian youth-novels was also selected. All novels were first published
in this century, 10 in each decade. Historical content of the novels was analyzed in terms of history
perceptions. (Which event/s are depicted and how they are presented.) Success of the books was
also measured by the number of published copies, the frequency of publications, etc.
Results are interpreted in terms of correspondences and deviations between two types
perceptions of history in relation to the relative success of the books. In a broader theoretical
framework, the role of literary narratives in constructing and maintaining national historical
narratives is analyzed.
Reading Holocaust Literature: An Interview Study
Elrud Ibsch and Margrit Schreier
We want to report about a project carried out in Germany, at the Psychological Institute of
the University of Cologne. Elrud Ibsch investigated reactions of German students (students of
German Language and Literature and students of psychology) to more or less experimental literary
texts dealing with the annihilation of European Jewry. The first part of the contribution (Elrud
Ibsch) will be devoted to a discussion of the use of qualitative methods (interviews, content
analysis), and the second part (Margrit Schreier) to the quantitative analysis of the verbal data.
Although the aim of the project was rather exploratory and not intended for an experimental testing
of hypotheses, we had some hypotheses in mind, such as (1) A high degree of literary socialization
will have a favorable influence on the acceptance of literary experiments about the Holocaust,
irrespective of the degree of historical knowledge and emotional involvement and (2) A high degree
of historical knowledge of the genocide and understanding of the current debate combined with low
literary socialization is supposed to have a restraining influence on the acceptance of experimental
literature.
Methods: Two pre-structured interviews were conducted with each of the participants. The
first (introductory) interview aimed to establish the independent variables historical knowledge and
interest, sources of knowledge, involvement or distance with respect to the theme, literary
socialization, concepts of literature, and specific experience with Holocaust literature. The second
interview was concerned with the interpretation and evaluation of three literary texts, which can be
conceived of as experimental in different ways (texts by Tabori, Hilsenrath, and Ransmayr). The
students had three to four weeks time between the interviews to read the texts. The verbal data were
interpreted according to the standard processes of content analysis and, in a second stage, subjected
to statistical analyses.
12. Symposium
GLOBALIZATION OF COMMUNICATION AND MEDIA
Gebhard Rusch
The development and history of mass media, such as books, magazines and newspapers,
radio and television and of course - the World Wide Web, was increasingly interregional,
international and intercultural from the beginning. In that sense, globalization is not an invention of
the so called information age. Know how, education, and cultural skills have been communicated
internationally or globally since international and global structures and relations had been
established by migration, commerce, and politics.
Globalization, as it is present for us today, is not an absolutely new kind of phenomenon,
but the result of an acceleration of technological innovation, the result of an extension of markets
(and marketing activities), and of the experience of omnipresent and permanent access to, or
availability of, transnational and transcultural contacts, products, and services.
The world was prepared and educated for the age of globalization since the first writings
had crossed cultural borderlines. The digital revolution now meets some of the expectations directed
towards a global society. What does that mean for communication and media, for literature and the
arts, for social structures and democracy?
Global Media Generations An Austrian Perspective
Theo Hug
At the beginning of the 21st century, it becomes obvious that the 20th century has shaped a
unique idea of a common global identity, which has been enhanced by the globalization of satellite
and computer technologies, by the international distribution of political, cultural and economical
events, the increasing relevance of international political alliance and cooperation, the awareness of
the global relation of the ecological environment, the awareness of the diversity of cultures across
the globe, a new notion of global risks and crises and a worldwide understanding of humanity and
democracy. The project "Global Media Generations 2000" makes a contribution to the
reconstruction of the memory of events in these areas, as they have become substantial elements of
individual views of the 'world,' of edcuation within an international community and of global
citizenship. It analyzes and interprets media related knowledge segments of different, globally
spread age cohorts. Furthermore, it is the goal of the project to promote the understanding of the
20th century by bringing to the fore media events of one century, not as historical 'facts' but as
substantial elements of a new global collective memory, across different generations and
geographical world regions. Along with the project approach and methodology some results of the
Austrian section are presented.
Internet Theory from a Constructivist Perspective
Martin Werle
Even though the Internet is by now an integral part of many people's lives, academic circles
still haven't come up with theoretical analyses or explanations. The need for appropriate Internet
theories is very high, though. A phenomenon that began as a technological experiment has started to
radically transform our lives, our way of thinking. In order to master this powerful movement, we
should create a viable theoretical background.
As a starting point for an Internet theory, I will analyse, how far the technical characteristics
of the Net determine its capacities and the users' behaviour in contact with it. To theoretically grasp
the new medium, a comparison to other mass media will be helpful. I will outline the similarities and
differences between the Internet and traditional mass media, especially TV.
The Internet's rapid growth and diversification in possibilities for using the Net requires an
analytical tool that is able to reflect and keep up with the continuous changes in the Net. The broad
dialogue within the field of constructivist theory make this school a promising candidate for the task
at hand. As theoretical takes on TV from a constructivist angle already exist, I will check whether
the criteria developed for TV can also be applied on the Internet. In this process the aspects
self-sustainability, operational impermeability, informational openness and self-referenciality
deserve special attention.
Internet Communication and Anonymity:
A Critical View on the Loss of Subjectivity
Reinhold Viehoff
A systemic and empirical approach to the study of communication, culture, and literature is
based on subjects and what they do, i.e., based on a theory of action. Individuality and subjectivity
are at the core of communication and the construction of any social fact, concepts which themselves
are the bases for all social and educational processes in modern Western societies. Based on the
work of Mead, Schütz, Parsons, Weber, and others, Juergen Habermas developed his ideas about
the universals of communication to explain how and why and by what means subjects find ways to
be social individuals. In Western cultures, communication between subjects in cultural, economic, or
scientific interaction is based on established rules. For example, in the area of literary and scientific
communication, a publication is validated if the text in question it has an author by name, contracts
are factors in the process of publication, etc. That is, the subject -- presented by his/her name -- is
witness to the inherent logic of social communication and to his/her self-identity. I argue that digital
communication (new technology, new media, the internet, the world wide web, etc.) weakens the
tradition and function of communication as we know it because of its ambiguous referential
structure. For example, participation in a chat-room, or on ICQ on the internet, the identity of the
subjects who communicate with each other may be simulated. My paper deals with the
consequences of such a fundamental change in communication, its social and personal function and
process. My discussion is an attempt to view the exchanges in a chat-room or on ICQ as a specific
manner of communication that, in turn, is literally "littering" the web in a more systematic
perspective. In order to illustrate my argument, I will present recent examples of digitalized
communication and anonymity.
Media Memories in American Voices:
GMG 2000
Matthew D. Payne
"The Problem of Generations" sets forward fundamental research questions, but it is with
Mannheim's research agenda in mind that we begin. "Such a wide problem can only be solved as a
result of cooperation between the most diverse disciplines and nationalities...planned and directed
from an organic center" (1952:287). This study embraces Mannheim's challenge to solve this
problem through international and interdisciplinary collaboration. In looking at how different
cultures across generations synthesize media into their everyday life, GMG 2000 has brought
together the most diverse disciplines and nationalities and the findings are fascinating. Some of the
American findings touch on how collective or individual media memories are, experiencing media
vs. owning media, media "moments" vs. media "spectacle," and how biographical and formative
media can be. When compared to other international findings, such as those from Austria,
interesting patterns emerge. The American findings and the international comparison/contrast that
will be focused on in this presentation.
13. SYMPOSIUM
REPUTATION FORMATION AND HIERARCHY-MAKING
IN LITERATURE AND THE ARTS
Susanne Janssen
The Reception of Proust and His Works in The Netherlands (1920-1997)
Sabine van Wesemael
Since Jauss's claim that the progressive character of literary works is decisive for its
reception, most studies into historical reception has greatly focused on academic criticism. However,
it remains to be seen whether a study into academic reception does represent general reception.
Studies into the reception of Proust by public criticism have shown this is not the case. Indeed, the
image round Proust's works as it comes to the fore in the public press differs more and more from
its image in international scholarly circles. This partly finds its explanation in developments within
the public press; traditional religious and socio-political barriers in the Netherlands are being
removed and the position of French language and culture has changed. But the fact that the nature
and objectives of the public press differ strongly from those of academic media is as important. For
instance, ideologies will influence public press to a lesser extent, these media rather focussing their
attention on personal reading experience and leaving more space for expressing personal judgment.
The theories and interpretations of French existentialists (such as Sartre), "nouveaux romanciers"
and followers of Jacques Lacan, for instance, have exerted a strong influence on Dutch romanists,
yet they have hardly affected the public press.
The Careers of Authors and Critics in the Cultural Field
Nel van Dijk
A longitudinal study into the careers of about fifty Dutch debutant authors from the
seventies indicated that success as a literary author is strongly related to attention from literary
critics. However, not only the number of reviews is important, but also the reputation of the
reviewer in question, and, with regard to the content of the review, the value judgement, and the way
a literary work is characterized. When it comes to the critical reception of a literary work, author
themselves are also important actors. Authors might exercise influence upon the reception of their
work, for example by the way they manifest themselves within the literary world.
In my paper I would like to report on new results of the research into reputations of literary
authors and critics. By means of a case study I explored what factors contribute to the rather
divergent developments in the critical appreciation of literary works. Looking over a considerable
period of time, two aspects turned out to be of major influence. First, the specific phase of a literary
career; is an author young and upcoming or is he or she an author 'of age'? Second, the way the
cultural constellation develops; institutions such as literary criticism, publishers, and the media are
constantly changing. The dynamics of the cultural field clearly affect the careers of individual
authors.
Who Are Judging the Arts in Public?
Attitudes, Careers, and Roles of Journalistic Art* Critics in The Netherlands,1968-2000
Susanne Janssen.
Cultural goods and activities are classified with respect to one another. Even though systems
of cultural classification present themselves as natural and enduring, they are products of human
action, continually subject to selection and change. An important role in the making and mediation
of cultural classifications is played by agents and institutions whose job it is to make (quality)
assessments with respect to the supply of cultural artifacts. Among these agents and institutions,
journalistic critics play a crucial part because their choices and judgements effect an initial sifting
and ranking of the culture on offer.
The present study sets out to shed light on the professional characteristics of this particular
class of cultural 'judges', drawing on a large scale survey among critics working in the Dutch daily
and weekly press. The results of this survey will be compared with the outcomes of a survey that
was held in 1968, to see what changes have occurred over time in the backgrounds, career paths,
personal attitudes, professional orientations and role conceptions of journalistic critics.
* art is used in a general sense, including literature, film, theater, etc.
Cultural Capital, Cultural Hierarchies and the Canon
Discussion in the USA and The Netherlands
Kees van Rees
Since its introduction by Bourdieu (1979) and its elaboration by DiMaggio (1982),
Ganzeboom (1984; 1989) and colleagues, the notion of cultural capital has assumed a central
position in the testing of theories on social and cultural reproduction, cultural mobility, and cultural
participation. This has led to an enriching of the social-economic stratification model with an
important cultural dimension. Cultural capital and related variables, such as cultural competence,
legitimate taste, and aesthetic disposition, were shown to play an intermediate role as determinants
of social-economic differences. Empirically oriented researchers are aware that quality and
properties are assigned to cultural items by critics and teachers, people professionally involved in
judging cultural items; they also admit that the intrinsic meaning and value of cultural items cannot
be assessed in an unequivocal manner, as the archimedean point required to achieve this is, and will
for ever be, lacking. Yet, both in the United States and Western Europe, school canons (the
composition of reading lists) and teachers' requirements are being discussed without sufficient
attention being payed to questions regarding institutional and social determinants of production
and consumption, and their interaction, which on its turn affects what we mean by cultural
competence and cultural capital. Classifications and hierarchies of cultural items are continuously
open to modification, for instance, through media discussions among artists, critics, politicians and
the audience.
In this paper I consider how in recent decades, the criteria by which cultural repertoires are
established have lost some of their discriminatory value. Cultural contents are more diversified,
genre classifications are being overstepped, there is less consensus in the field about what is
legitimate art, and the number of legitimizing agents seems to have multiplied. Everything seems to
indicate that this border erosion within and between cultural fields corresponds to processes of
increased social mobility and individualization not only in Dutch society but also in the USA. A
second trend is that of globalization of cultural contents. For many years, national culture was the
primary object of canon formation in the service of national identity formation. In the Netherlands,
for instance, national literature and, in the US, literature of Anglo-Saxon inspiration constituted the
reference point for canon formation at school (Moerbeek 1998; Tanja Janssen 1998; Corse 1996;
Bryson 2000). In recent decades, however, this has become at best one of many options. This is
partly due to the increase in international traffic, enabling humans to cross limits of time and space,
and new forms of electronic media which permit instantaneous communication of and interaction on
ideas, images, and sounds of different cultures. At the same time, and this is a third trend, there is an
increasing segmentation of cultural preferences: while at an individual or subgroup level preferences
may remain relatively stable, they are no longer generally shared. For individuals or smaller groups,
they relate, instead, to a specific genre or a particular set of cultural goods. As a consequence, a
gradually more global culture tends to include a growing number of special interest groups, each
focussing on a small number of cultural expressions and goods.
Processes of erosion, globalization and segmentation occur in all cultural domains, and with
respect to literature, in particular in the formal repertoires transmitted by the education system.
Twenty-five years ago, there was greater consensus on Dutch literature and on the ranking of
authors who constituted the school canon. Since then, this consensus has slowly eroded: today,
there are hardly any standard lists in secondary education, and the texts chosen belong to various
genres, several of which did not even count as literature in the past. Therefore, the present cultural
classification system appears less hierarchical, less universal and, within cultural sectors (pop music,
plastic arts) more differentiated. On the basis of an integrated approach, that is, by taking account
of the interrelated processes in the fields of production and consumption, more specifically, by
paying due attention to the changes on the dimensions of late twentieth century art classification
systems, researchers of cultural stratification will be in the position to answer more satisfactorily
the question of which cultural traits, which modes of cultural capital, and which types of cultural
socialization appear most effective.
Types of Expertise Attributed to Reviewers of Literature
Hugo Verdaasdonk
We collected longitudinal data on the selections made by the compilers of LiteRom, a CD
featuring over 50,000 reviews of new literary releases spanning the period 1900-2000. These
selections form a pattern that develops over time. A large group of critics appeared to be selected at
most three times as commentators of subsequent new releases by one and the same author; a much
smaller group of reviewers was selected more than three times (in some cases up to 14 times) as
commentators of subsequent new releases by one and the same author. The first group of critics
seem to be credited with having essentially comprehensive expertise: although the number of
subsequent new releases by one and the same author they are allowed to review on LiteRom is
strictly limited, they are chosen as reviewers of a wide array of authors. Critics who are selected
more than three times as reviewers of subsequent new releases by one and the same author seem to
be credited with expert knowledge on this author; at the same time, they are also credited with
having comprehensive literary knowledge: they review a wide array of new releases by various
authors on LiteRom. We constructed two covariates, one measuring comprehensive literary
knowledge, the other specialist expertise on individual authors. Each of these covariates used data
on previous choices made by the compilers of LiteRom. The results of event history analysis
showed that the first covariate significantly affected the selections of reviewers belonging to the first
group and that both covariates significantly affected the selections of critics in the second group.
Each of the covariates needs a different period of time to have impact on the chance that critics in
the first or in the second group are included in LiteRom.
14. Symposium
TEXT, PERFORMANCE, AND REFLECTION:
METHODS OF ACCESS TO LITERARY READING
Don Kuiken
Literary reading is an event that characteristically involves the confluence of three textual
structures. The first is the text itself, a structure that, like a musical score, shapes and constrains
reading performances. The second is the reading performance, a structure produced through the
reader's immediate embodiment and elaboration of the structure provided by the text itself. The
third is reflection on the reading performance, a structure created through retrospective
consideration of and communication about the immediate reading experience. This symposium will
provide comparative analysis of the methods by which investigators obtain empirical access to this
concatenation of textual structures:
Focusing on retrospective comments on the reading performance, Don Kuiken will
articulate the rationale for phenomenological analyses of readers' reflections on the reading
experience. To demonstrate this approach, he will describe how numerically aided phenomenology
has been used to systematically identify classes (or types) of reading experience, including a form
of expressive enactment that resembles classical accounts of aesthetic experience.
Focusing on the reading performance, Art Graesser will present an integrated approach to
the investigation of literary comprehension that involves: (1) dissection of the text at multiple levels
of language and discourse structure; (2) evaluation of the extent to which a population of readers
has mastered each level of discourse structure; (3) specification of theories, models or hypotheses
in sufficient detail to provide discriminating predictions; and (4) collecting behavioral data to test
those predictions.
Focusing on the text itself, Colin Martindale will present the general principles of content
analysis and related procedures. To exemplify this mode of analysis, he will describe how the
primordial content analysis approach was used to analyze British, French, and American historical
trends in poetry. To indicate the utility of this approach, he will demonstrate its use in author
attribution, identifying poets' temperaments, and inferring the meaning of a narrative from trends in
primordial content.
Focusing on accounts of absorption in reading, Ingrid Braun and Gerry Cupchik had
respondents describe their reactions to self-selected materials and to those of the experimenters.
The phenomenological aspects of reader responses involving time, space, causality, and materiality,
were related to perceived text qualities. They also rated the materials on various 7-point scales and
their judgments were factor analyzed. Relations between the qualitative and quantitative data sets
will be described.
Discussion after these presentations will compare and contrast the assumptions that guide
the selection and implementation of these methods of textual analysis. The presenters will try to
identify the research contexts within which each approach has its greatest utility.
Phenomenological Methods for Articulating Types of Reading Experience
Don Kuiken
Phenomenologically grounded methods of inquiry pursue questions of kind: For example,
what are the attributes of a reading experience such that, when they are expressed in a narrative
describing that experience, that narrative is an expression of an "aesthetic experience"? Usually the
phenomenon of interest is tacitly known. For instance, it is assumed that the investigator can
recognize when an experiential narrative describes an "aesthetic experience." With that confidence,
the investigator then examines a set of narratives (e.g., think-aloud protocols in a study of literary
reading) to identify the attributes that are invariably present in descriptions of an "aesthetic
experience." Also, in that confidence, the investigator can even examine narrative variations in
imagination to discern those attributes. By systematically imagining possible modifications of
concretely given narratives, the investigator presumably can uncover the essence of the
phenomenon.
Difficulties arising from the use of imaginative variation motivated the development of
numerically aided phenomenology (Kuiken, Schopflocher, & Wild, 1989; Kuiken & Miall, 1995).
In this approach, recurrent meaning expressions are identified and paraphrased within a set of
experiential narratives. Then judgments about their presence or absence are used to create matrices
reflective of the profiles of meanings expressed in each experiential narrative. Finally, cluster
analytic algorithms are used to group these experiential narratives according to the similarities in
their profiles of meaning expressions. In this way, classes of similarly reported experiences - and
their distinctive attributes - can be systematically identified. A phenomenological study of literary
reading will be used to highlight: (1) how the pre-theoretical explication of recurrent meaning
expressions differs from content analysis; (2) how the polythetic classes resulting from numerically
aided phenomenology resist "operational definition"; and (3) how the description of these classes
of experience can rigorously and sensitively capture the lived experience of literary reading.
Language and Discourse Structure During the Reading of Literary Texts
Art Graesser
Discourse psychologists have analyzed the process of comprehending and appreciating
literary texts for approximately two decades. A good theory can specify the representations that are
constructed at different levels, the process of constructing these representations on-line during
reading, and the utilization of these representations in subsequent cognitive tasks (such as recall,
summarization, question answering, verification of test statements, and various ratings). On-line
reading processes are tapped by methods that collect reading times for constituents (e.g., word,
phrase, sentence, paragraph), eye tracking data, or quick responses to test words that occur shortly
after text constituents (e.g., word naming, lexical decisions, speeded word recognition judgments).
An adequate test of the theories involves four prongs: (1) dissection of the text at multiple levels of
language and discourse structure, (2) evaluation of the extent to which a population of readers has
mastered each level of language and discourse structure, (3) specification of theories, models, or
hypotheses in sufficient detail to provide discriminating predictions, and (4) collecting behavioral
data to test the predictions. All bets are off when testing theories if any of these four prongs are
missing or underdeveloped.
My presentation will focus on analyses of language and discourse structure. One central
challenge is to formulate an experimental design that adequately tests whether a particular level of
language or discourse is truly constructed on-line. For example, does the reader construct
inferences about characters' motives, spatial layout, characters' emotions, or a global theme of a
literary story? Does the reader construct a pragmatic dialog between narrator and narratee, or
between the writer and reader? Does the reader have remindings of previous experiences while
reading a narrative? Does a reader bask in appreciation of a particular statement, episode, or literary
device? How would one design an experiment to rigorously assess these possibilities?
Content Analysis and Lexical Statistics as Tools
for the Empirical Study of Literature
Colin Martindale
If theorists (e.g., Stanley Fish) were correct in their assertions that people show virtually no
agreement in their interpretations of literary texts, then the content of such texts would be of little
interest in reader-response experiments. However, quantitative studies have shown that people
actually agree very well in their interpretation of texts. Given this, to understand why readers
respond in the ways they do, it is important to have measures of text content and structure. Content
analysis is a data-reduction technique in which we "translate" large numbers of words into a single
meta-word or content category (e.g., aggression, love).
To demonstrate why content analysis is necessary for literary analysis, comparison with the
study of individual differences is useful. Although all people are unique, in the scientific study of
individual differences, we group people into a small number of categories or array them along a
small number of dimensions. It is of scientific interest to know that extraverts are less inhibited than
introverts, but it is of no scientific interest to know whether I am more or less inhibited than Gerry
Cupchik. Similarly, in general, the idiographic study of individuals or works of literature is a matter
for biographers or literary critics rather than for scientists. To study literature scientifically, we need
content analysis (as well as lexical statistics such as average sentence length, the type-token ratio,
etc.) to assess an author's state of mind.
I have developed a content analysis dictionary that gets at primordial vs. conceptual content.
The dictionary has allowed me to test my theory of aesthetic evolution on the history of American,
British, and French poetry. Because of the large amounts of texts that had to be analyzed, this could
not have been done without a content analytic "mnemonic" device. The dictionary has also been
useful in decoding the symbolic meaning of different classes of narratives. Other dictionaries have
been useful in the study of author attribution, but idiosyncratic differences in the use of common
function words are usually more useful in such studies.
The Phenomenology of Absorption in Literary Texts
Ingrid Braun & Gerald Cupchik
What does it mean to be lost in a book? A casual glance at this phenomenon demonstrates
that when absorbed by a text, a reader experiences another reality, albeit not as poignantly as
"normal" reality. The focus of this study is concerned with how readers construct their experience
of reading. Specifically, what are the components of this experience, how do readers construct them,
and how do they fit together to form the whole experience? To this end, a method is offered which
seeks to elucidate these experiential qualities via a phenomenological analysis of participants'
respondents to interview questions.
Reader absorption implies an understanding about the absorbing text, so delineating the
processes involved in reading is a prudent first step towards understanding reader absorption.
There are three phases to this study, and each consists of an interview which was ultimately
transcribed. Interviews were conducted with 24 participants (12 females, 12 males) who
demonstrated familiarity with being lost in a book. These interviews were analyzed for meaningful
elements in order to illuminate the experiential components of the reading process.
Phase I consisted wholly of an interview in which participants answered questions geared to
elicit responses regarding the experiential components of the reading process. Phase II was an
exploration of the more cognitive aspects of how readers develop meaning on-line. It included a
reading task in which participants read two of four literary passages and a questionnaire. Phase III
involved a short discussion of a well-liked passage of the participant's choice. These protocols were
analyzed for common statements about how it feels to be lost in a book.
The results from Phase I revealed reading processes involved in experience construction by
articulating them as categories. Analysis also demonstrated that two types of readers, each
differentiated by level of critical analysis skills, generated further subcategories which manifested
themselves along a continuum. Phase II revealed additional processes involved in meaning
construction. Phase III data illustrated how the experiential and meaning components work in
conjunction to create an absorbing reading experience.
15. Paper Session
CROSS-CULTURAL DYNAMICS
Motivations to Study Literature and Interests in Reading in
Different Cultures and Societies: Brazil and Germany in Comparison
Achim Barsch, Sonia Zyngier, Andrea Claudia Valente, & Marcello Pinto
Why do students choose to study literature i.e. literary scholarship (Literarturwissenschaft)?
What are their expectations for their studies? What kind of literature and media are they fond of?
What interests in reading do they have? What kind of concepts of literature do they use? These are
questions teachers of literature normally put in introductory courses at universities. In a pilot study,
a questionnaire dealing with these different topics was used in several courses. A second study has
been conducted in Rio de Janeiro in September 1999 and in Siegen again in Winter 1999/2000.
The paper will give some of the results gained, will discuss methodological and crosscultural
aspects, and will present some implications for the teaching of literature.
Reading Literature and Reading for Literature:
The Brazilian Concept of Literary Awareness.
Marcello de Oliveira Pinto
Based upon the concepts of literary action as developed by the Empirical Science of
Literature, I aim to discuss the concept of literary awareness by analyzing a set of post-processual
constructs (literary interpretations) of undergraduate students as proposed in the research
Construtos Pós-processuais e Conscientização Literária: Uma Investigação Empírica (Pinto,
2000). In order to so, I took as a starting point the literary awareness process proposed by Zyngier
(1994,1996). In her research, she conceptualized a literary course that aimed to activate the reader's
capacity for perceiving the linguistic resources in a literary text. Through oriented activities, these
readers would develop abilities that enabled them to understand the mechanisms of language
involved in the construction of texts and the materialization of these linguistic choices in a text.
These activities are part of the Portuguese-English Graduation course at the Faculty of Letters in the
Federal University of Rio de Janeiro.
My research project aimed at understanding if the post-processual constructs produced by
the students of Zyngier´s literary awareness course reveal their awareness of the reading process.
This would make them second order observers of the reading process. I conducted an investigation
of the constructs done at the two extremes of the course. The first one was the reading of Blake´s
The Lamb at the ouset of the course. At the end of the course, students were given an opportunity to
modify their original interpretations. The research reveals how students changed their constructs but
were not necessarily aware of themselves as acting in the literature system.
Form Symbolism and Danish, Slovenian, and Japanese Subjects
John Kennedy, Chang Hong Liu, Bradford Challis & Victor Kennedy
Simple geometrical forms such as a circle and a square can be symbolic. For example , a
circle can be taken to be "soft" and a square to be "hard". The relations between circle and square
and possible symbolic referents were tested using subjects in three countries: Denmark, Slovenia
and Japan. The three groups of subjects come from distinct language groups. Nevertheless, the
three groups of subjects selected the same referents for the forms to a remarkable extent. The
results suggest symbolic forms may have referents as a result of semantic processes that are alike in
users of different languages. That is, symbolic matches are independent of the closeness of the
languages of the subjects. We suggest subjects match features of the forms with features of the
referents.
Knowledge Explosion as a Development Explosion: A Sociological Appraisal
Mohammad Taghi Sheykhi
The paper explores that knowledge explosion in the modern age functions as the main and
extraordinary driving force to enhance development. Although the expansion of knowledge initially
started from Europe, it has extensively grown in various parts of the world, but in different scales
and dimensions. Knowledge is at the turn of century substituting for other factors of production
such as raw materials, labour, and capital. While human development owes greatly to knowledge,
explosion of knowledge, too, is the result of human development. Likewise, promotion of welfare,
better standards, more securities, richer leisure times, higher longevity, eugenics etc., all are outputs
of knowledge explosion. Testing laboratories, norms and standards, and quality control centres, as
key and determining centres, owe much to the development of knowledge. Although knowledge has
divided the world into fast-moving and slow-moving regions, the developing countries are focussing
on specific forms of knowledge to improve their agricultural productivity. At the international level,
too, transfer of capital by the rich countries to developing countries is extensively encouraged so as
to help them marshal knowledge more effectively for development.
Education, being a key factor in sustainable development, is at the same time a component of
well-being, and a factor in the development of well-being through its links with the social and
economic factors. Hence, gaining access to knowledge is counted as a pre-condition for coping in
today's complex world. Access to knowledge, especially by the young people, prepares them to
cope with the fast-changing world, i.e., for their career development and professional life. Also, in
the process of knowledge development, gender equity, and an unprejudiced atmosphere are
recommended.
Deviant Typology in Persian Literature
Rahmatallah Seddigh Servestani
Some new theories of deviance and criminology can be divided into three major groups. The
first group asserts that deviants are biologically pre-disposed towards crime. Scholars such as
Lombroso and Sheldon side with the idea that some acts are inherently "criminal." The second
group emphasizes the psychological basis of human conduct, arguing, as in Freud's psychoanalytic
theory, that personality disorders cause the deviant behavior. The third group believes in the social
origin of behavior, one subgroup identifying motive-driven deviants and another perceiving
sub-cultures and their effects as the major causes of deviance.
While the above theories go back to the nineteenth century at the earliest, the etiology of
social behavior and deviance has been discussed in various types of Persian literature several
centuries earlier. This study presents and critiques the views of two Iranian scholars; Sa'di Shirazi
and Khajeh Naseereddin Toosi. Belonging to the post-Mongolian-invasion era (thirteenth century),
both of these very eminent scholars mostly examined the human lifestyle and social conduct.
Sa'di asserts, by way of numerous fables and poems, that there are two different types of
human nature. One is noble and pure (Gohare Neek), and the other base and vile (Gohare Bad). He
believes that human behavior is only temporarily shaped by society, being ultimately determined by
the person's nature. In his fables, a person's bad nature will eventually lead to abnormality and
deviance, regardless of his continued association with people of noble spirit.
On a similar tone, Khajeh Naseereddin insists that, with respect to social conduct, the nature
of a person places him in one of five different groups. At one extreme, the nature is good, pure
enough to propagate to others. At the other extreme, it is vile, depraved enough to diffuse
throughout society. This study investigates the literary works of Sa'di and Khajeh Naseereddin
relevant to theories of deviance. It explores the concept of "nature" and groups of people discussed
by these two scholars.
16. PERFORMANCE PIECE
The Amateur and Atelier in Musical Experience:
An Experiment in Embodied Aesthetic Education
Deanne Bogdan (piano)
Brenda Enns (soprano)
Alan Stellings (cello)
Cultural critic Edward Said stresses the idea of the amateur in musical performance in its
etymological sense of "amatus" or "lover." In approaching the musical work as an amateur, there is
a progressive de-objectification in the matrix of dynamics that exists between the work and the
players, the players and composer, the historical and cultural milieux of the players and the work,
the players, and listeners. The work is then seen to function dually as a catalyst for this
multi-faceted dynamic and as a symbol for the personalization process we recognize as aesthetic
experience.
In this presentation three musicians (a pianist, cellist, and soprano) will conduct an
experiment in musical performing and listening in the spirit of the amateur, i.e., the lover of music.
By regarding the audience as co-participants, we explore some of the multi-layered facets of
aesthetic experience through the interspersing of live musical performance with verbal and visual
text in an ever-evolving constructed event among the composer(s), piece(s), performer(s), and
listeners.Building on Roland Barthes's prescribed conditions for the survival of "classical" music in
the twenty-first century, we seek to show that, in order for music not to be passively consumed, the
conventional division between audience and performer of the concert hall must be replaced by the
intersubjective dynamics of what Barthes calls "a studio, a workshop, and atelier." We believe this
potential for embodied musical experience holds promise for aesthetic education. In our live
performance presentation, we attempt to forge links between past, present, composer, work,
performer, and listener by playing two of Robert and Clara Schumann's works for piano and cello
and contextualizing them within a multi-modal format through the use of diaries, letters, secondary
biographical and historical material, photographs, and poetry, thus illustrating and enacting the
concepts of the amateur, the atelier, and embodied musical experience.
17. Symposium
THE NARRATIVE OF EMOTION
Shakespeare's Invention of Theater as a Mental Model of the World,
A Place of Emotions and Ethical Reflection
Keith Oatley
Harold Bloom has argued that Shakespeare's big innovation was inventing the idea of
human personality. I want to make a similarly sweeping claim, but a different one. Shakespeare's
great innovation was his idea of theatre as a model of the world, that could be constructed as a
mental model by his audience and readers. One sees this not just in his calling his theatre "The
Globe," and in well-known speeches like "All the world's a stage" but in the deep structure of his
plays. Shakespeare's idea was to take seriously the idea that Aristotle called mimesis, and that
nowadays we might call simulation. Shakespeare was influenced by Erasmus who argued that what
appears on the surface of human life is not typically what is important for our understanding.
Shakespeare's innovation was to show a particular kind of life, in the theatre, as a way of
simulating the interactions of people with their predicaments so that the deep structure of selfhood
and social interaction becomes clear. I will explore this idea by analyses of Henry IV part 1, and
Hamlet. I will also argue that as we run such simulations on our own minds, we not only experience
the emotions and hence the urgency of the human vicissitudes and dilemmas that cause them, but
we are enabled to reflect on them in such a way as to create deeper level mental models of ourselves
and others
Toward an Affective Rhetoric
James Averill
Great literature, it is often suggested, appeals to universal human emotions. I would offer a
different suggestion. Great literature refines, stretches, and ultimately transforms our emotions.
These suggestions reflect two very different views of emotion: According to the first, emotions--at
least the so-called "basic" emotion--are unchanging, innate responses that remain invariant over time
and across cultures; according to the second, emotions are subject to creative change, and one
function of art and literature is to facilitate such change. Put differently, what lends great literature
its appeal is not that it taps into preestablished emotions, but that it challenges us to experience new
and different emotions. In this presentation, I draw on one form of literature--namely, rhetoric--as a
model for analyzing emotional innovation and change. Today, rhetoric is often viewed negatively, as
glib or flamboyant speech intended to manipulate rather than inform. But that has not always been
the case. The speeches of classical orators, such as Cicero, are still read, not for the message they
contain (which may be of historical interest only), but for their literary value. At its best, rhetoric has
aesthetic and creative qualities comparable to other forms of literature; conversely, other forms
literature often have didactic or persuasive qualities comparable to rhetoric. Thus, it is not surprising
that two recent texts, Contemporary Literary Theory (Atkins & Morrow, 1989) and Contemporary
Perspectives on Rhetoric (Foss, Foss, & Trapp, 1991) overlap considerably in content, even though
they differ in format and emphasis.
The purpose of this presentation is primarily theoretical; taking a lead from Aristotle (1941),
its goal is to illuminate the nature of emotion by drawing on insights gained from the study of
rhetoric, and vice versa. But there is a practical concern as well, one of more interest perhaps to
emotion researchers than to literary critics. As implied above, emotions do not spring from the
human brain, preformed, like Minerva from the head of Zeus. Rather, emotions are constructed
"on-line" as an episode develops, a process known as microgenesis. Research on the microgenesis
of emotional episodes can be difficult and time-consuming. For example, Peery (1978) advocates
the use of an "affective microscope"--a frame by frame analysis of a videotape, or word by word
analysis of a verbal transcript. Few investigators have the resources or patience for such efforts;
nor is an "affective microscope" the most appropriate tool for the task. An "affective rhetoric" is
proposed instead. This approach focuses on the meaning of an emotional episode, its potential
effects on a target and audience; most importantly, an affective rhetoric recognizes the potential for
creativity in the domain of emotion, as in the domains of art and literature.
Emotional Narratives and Psychological Well-Being
Nancy L. Stein & Tom Trabasso
An on-line theory of emotional understanding will be used to illustrate ways in which
narrative and argumentative reports of emotional experience can be parsed, analyzed, and used to
predict memory, understanding, learning, and psychological well being. Our analysis of emotional
experience has been used to code over 10,000 narratives and conflict reports from children as
young as 3 to adults as old as 83. The theory allows us to code the semantic content and causal
structure of any report of emotional experience, be it in narrative or argument form. We do so in an
exhaustive fashion with respect to the content of any report. Our analysis of talk that accompanies
emotional experience is used in conjunction with analyses of the nonverbal parts of emotional
experience that focus on physiology, thinking, and action. We argue that the organization of
emotional experience, despite its diversity and complexity, is highly constrained over age, culture,
and gender. We also argue that despite the intensity of certain types of emotional talk and
appraisals, only emotion talk that is linked to planning and future oriented action is predictive of
memory, mental health, and well-being.
To illustrate the power of our analysis, we present results from studies on trauma, stressful
events, conflictual interaction, and negotiation. We show the types of discourse that define
emotional experience, the ways in which emotions can be distinguished from other affective states,
and the predictive power of specific emotions during individual private interviews and face-to-face
interaction. We describe the ways in which emotions, beliefs, goals, and actions are linked together,
and the ways in which emotions predict the appraisals that people make about one another. Finally,
we show how our analysis of emotional experience predicts accurate memory for events as well as
states of psychological well-being (e.g., depression, anger, happiness).
18. Symposium
LITERATURE AND PEOPLE'S LIVES
Jèmeljan Hakemulder
Naivete and Corruption: Empirical Considerations
Michael DePaul
In the following passage from Book II of Plato's Republic, Socrates claims
that the stories told children must be regulated:
- You know, don't you, that the beginning of any process is most important,
- especially for anything young and tender? It's at that time that it is most
- malleable and takes on any pattern one wishes to impress on it.
- Exactly.
- Then shall we allow the children to hear any old stories, told by just
- anyone, and to take beliefs into their souls that are for the most part
- opposite to the ones we think they should hold when they are grown up?
- We certainly won't.
- Then we must first of all, it seems, supervise the storytellers. We'll
- select their stories whenever they are fine or beautiful and reject them
- when they aren't. And we'll persuade nurses and mothers to tell their
- children the ones we have selected, since they will shape their children's
- souls with stories much more than they shape their bodies by handling them.
- Many of the stories they tell, however, must be thrown out. (337b-c)
Now consider a couple of familiar passages from early in Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethic.
- A young man is not a proper hearer of lectures on political science; for he
- is inexperienced in the actions that occur in life, but its discussions
- start from these and are about these. (1095a)
- Any one who is to listen intelligently to lectures about what is noble and
- just and, generally, about the subjects of political science must have been
- brought up in good habits. (1095b)
It seems to me that together these passages from very early on in the history of philosophy
suggest a striking view regarding who is fit to engage in ethical inquiry. To profitably engage in
ethical inquiry, one must have been well brought up. In large part, this means one needs to have had
an adequate breadth of experiences that, for the most part, were of the right sort. One significant
type of experience included here is listening to stories. In my paper, I will spell out some of the
philosophical implications of this view, which I find both interesting and plausible. Some of these
implications are empirical, and I will pay special attention to these.
Life Stories, Literary Aesthetics, and Literary Effects
Richard Gerrig
Many discussions of literature's effects on readers' beliefs, attitudes, and behavior have
focused on literary content as only a collection of facts. For example, researchers who have
considered the impact of violent content have often examined only the presence or absence of
violence. I suggest that, in addition, researchers should be attentive to the ways in which the
unfolding of causes and consequences in literary narratives affect readers' plans and expectations
for their own day-to-day experiences. In particular, readers may apply intuitive theories of literary
aesthetics to their own life stories.
The Sound of Meaning
Mike Wiseman & Willie van Peer
Literary critics and literary scholars regularly are involved in interpretations of texts that
assign meaning to sound patterns of the language, for instance when they interpret a conglomerate
of fricatives such as /f/ and /s/ as a 'symbol' of the wind, as in Coleridge's
- The fair breeze blew, the white foam flew,
- The furrow followed free;
- We were the first that ever burst
- Into that silent sea
(from The Rime of the Ancient Mariner).
Such interpretations are predicated on the assumption that language phonemes can and do
indeed transmit meanings of a sort. This assumption runs counter, however, to the wide consensus
in linguistics, going back to Saussure, that the relation between language phonemes and the
meaning of words is arbitrary. To our knowledge, the assumption that this relation may acquire a
different dimension for some purposes, for instance in the realm of aesthetics, has never been
tested. Such is the aim of the present paper.
The association of sound with the concept Rabbit (R) and Poisonous Snake (PS) was
examined using the conjoint measurement model with the two factors Consonant and Vowel, each
with three levels: "K", Ts" and "N" and "ah", "oh" and "ieh" respectively. Likert scales derived
from polyadic structured interviews in the context of both animals were also collected. The relative
importances of the two factors and the utilities of the levels and relationships with the Likert scales
were examined. It was hypothesized that the "hard" consonants "K" and "Ts" and the "close" vowel
"ieh" would be associated with PS, the "soft" consonant "N" and the open vowels "ah" and "oh"
with R. The hypothesis for the consonant was strongly supported, that for the vowels rejected.
Consonants received clearly higher
importance weights. The correlations of the utility values with the Likert scales provide further
insight into the meaning of sound.
19. Paper Session
READING PROCESSES: IV
Embodied Reading, Reintegrating Sensibility, and Feminist Pedagogy
Deanne Bogdan & Hilary Davis
Almost forty years after the publication of Northrop Frye's The Educated Imagination, it is
evident that the conceptual framework underlying Frye's theories has been a major touchstone for
the method and study of literature. Within reader response theory, however, it poses some
problems. First, literary experience is normatively conceived as "virtual." Second, Frye's critical
system posits a disembodied reader for whom literary experience is a case of T.S. Eliot's
"dissociation of sensibility." The first part of this paper examines some ethical and pedagogical
implications -- and applications -- of re-integrating/embodying experience that is so often
fragmented when literary experience is regarded as a form of the "real" experience of real readers
reading within a pluralistic educational setting.
Embodied readers are not only situated as to race, class, gender, and multifarious
considerations of difference, but with respect to how they are positioned along the continuum of a
"sovereign" or a "regressed" reading ego (Nell,1988). That is, any one act of literary engagement
will be contingent upon individual readers' relationship to the content and context of the reading
material in terms of what we refer to as the reader's "feeling, power, and location problems." The
second part of the paper offers an approach to embodied reading which marries Frye's aim of
reintegrating Eliot's dissociation of sensibility with some of the principles of feminist pedagogy, in
which reader's situated-ness in an increasingly variegated learning environment is taken seriously.
Through building on "the logical priority of direct response," it is hoped that the field-tested
exercises offered in this presentation and their underlying theory can enable better instances of
reintegrating sensibility in literature classes such that literary reading becomes what Frye called "a
means of conscious life."
The Golden apples of the sun: An exploratory investigation into the pre-eminence
of emotion over cognition in moments of 'literary bliss'
Michael Burke
This exploratory paper shall attempt to address two connected issues. The first of these
concerns the types of emotions that are generated during the act of reading literary texts. In this
section, I shall look at how these literary emotions might be categorized. I shall then move on to
concentrate on what are sometimes termed epiphanic moments in the literary reading adventure,
which may be linguistically or thematically triggered. These highly emotive events bring us to the
second, somewhat contentious topic: that concerning whether or not, in specific literary
environments, certain aspects of emotion are capable of momentarily bypassing the cognitive
workings of the mind.
This claim is not as radical as it at first sight may appear. In mainstream (emotive)
psychology, Zajonc (1984), without fully resurrecting the James-Lange theory, has argued quite
convincingly, against the majority of his colleagues, that since some emotional reactions are
sometimes quicker than our cognitive interpretation of the situation, we may sometimes feel an
emotion before we cognitively apprehend it. As a result of the subsequent neurological research
supporting this claim, there has been some acceptance that a quick, automatic emotional response,
momentarily eluding cognition, is possible. But this research was conducted with regard to real
world emotions, an environment, which arguably might lend itself, in certain situations, to the
primacy of physiological arousal over the perceived, and hence, cognitively processed, stimulus.
What I wish to discuss here is whether or not one can speak of a pre-eminence of emotion over
cognition during states of 'literary bliss' in reader-reception in that most cognitive of realms;
literary discourse processing, and indeed whether or not this can be tested empirically. In a tentative
theory based on a personal, emotive, 'reflection' of a past-locative event, experienced during
moments of 'literary bliss', I shall be suggesting that emotion may sometimes appear to be pre
eminent in parts of the literary reading experience.
Inspired by the work of Miall and Kuiken and their research team, and Oatley and his
research team, this paper shall attempt to address this issue and hopefully generate a meaningful
discussion on the cognition-emotion dichotomy in the processing of emotive literary text fragments.
Such a discussion may actually result in raising more questions than it answers. But these are
fundamentally inescapable issues that are pertinent to both literary aesthetics and general studies in
aesthetics alike, and as such warrant meaningful investigation.
My Mistress' Eyes Are Nothing Like The Sun:
Tenor, Vehicle, and Predicate in Simile Comprehension
David Fishelov
The purpose of this paper is to report a few interesting and important findings of an
empirical research investigating the process of understanding similes. The research was based on a
long questionnaire consisting of a list of about thirty similes. For each simile, subjects were asked
to respond in three ways: (a) to grade the degree of difficulty they encounter in understanding it; (b)
to estimate whether the simile conveys to them negative, positive or neutral connotations; and (c)
finally, to provide a short interpretation of the simile. Thus, for example, responding to the simile
(1) "John is like a snake," most subjects reported (a) that they have no difficulty in understanding it;
(b) that it conveys negative connotations; and (c) the simile says that John is a cunning, unreliable
and dangerous person. Other, more "difficult" similes got diversified answers. Thus, for example,
some subjects claimed that they have difficulty in understanding a phrase like (2) "John is like a
stork," and responses concerning its connotations and its specific meanings were more
heterogeneous.
In the research, I wanted to provide a systematic account of how do actual readers process
and interpret similes, with a special attention given to the semantic relationship between its three
major components: Tenor, Vehicle and Predicate. More specifically, I wanted to corroborate the
hypothesis that there is not necessarily a direct correlation between the explicitness of the simile
i.e., whether or not the Predicate is mentioned (e.g., the cunning in example 1) and the degree of
consensus obtained in its understanding. The research clarifies the process of understanding
similes, and, by implication, on our understanding of metaphors and symbols.
20. Invited Address
TOWARD A COMPREHENSIVE THEORY OF DRAMA APPRECIATION
Dolf Zillmann
A theory of drama appreciation is outlined and employed to explain the involvement with,
and especially the enjoyment of, fictional and nonfictional exposition. Involvement with, and
enjoyment of, non-mediated, directly witnessed dramatic events are also addressed, and the affinity
between emotional reactions to expositions of dramatic occurrences and the immediate observation
of these occurrences is examined. The theory emphasizes the function of normative and esoteric
moral judgment in the formation of emotional dispositions. Respondents to drama in fiction and in
reality formats are thought to continually monitor and evaluate all relevant happenings in moral
terms. The moral approval of agents' conduct is expected to yield friend-like appraisals, the moral
condemnation of their conduct enemy-like appraisals. The resulting dispositions are considered to
govern hopes and fears concerning actions directed at, and outcomes experienced by, persons and
other entities toward whom the dispositions are held. These dispositions determine anticipatory
emotions, such as suspense, and emotions in response to unfolding events of consequence, such as
joy for morally approved outcomes and dismay for outcomes that are deemed morally inappropriate
and regrettable. In this dispositional control of affective responding, the moral override of empathy,
especially the conversion of empathic to counter-empathic responding, is considered pivotal. The
override mechanism is used to explain, among other things, the callousness manifest in the joyful
response to others' suffering, such as the antagonists' punitive brutalization and cruel, even sadistic,
destruction. These basic mechanisms are supplemented by psychophysiological rationales.
Specifically, three-factor theory of emotion and excitation-transfer theory are applied to explain the
intensity of joyous reactions to dramatic events per se, but also the intensification of joyous
reactions by excitatory residues from preceding experiences of suspense and empathic distress.
Research demonstrations pertinent to these invoked mechanisms are summarized. They are drawn
from our work on the enjoyment of generic drama, suspense, horror, comedy, athletic competition,
and the revelation of salient events by the news.
21. Symposium
ENTERTAINING MEDIA: I
Media contents and their entertaining effects are the focus of this symposium. It deals with
different kind of media, taking both the perspective of the media and the users. The field's relevance
derives from the growing number of readers, listeners and viewers, spending most of their media-
time on "being entertained" (which is why "entertainment" has become one of the most important
goals of numerous media). Compared to its growing importance, however, empirical research on
entertaining media is still in its infancy.
Vorderer opens the symposium with an overview of the field of research and addresses the
very meaning of "being entertained." He will speak about fundamental theories and recent
developments, including interactive media and new perspectives on users and effects.
The five reports by current and past students from Hannover give examples of recent
research on entertaining media, encompassing visionary forms such as interactive films.
The first two reports deal with one of the most popular TV formats in Germany, daily talk
shows. Trepte and Zapfe examine viewer expectations of talk shows and the meaning of these
shows as a communication platform. Sudhoff and Trepte focus on parasocial relationships between
viewers and hosts of these daily talk shows. Parasocial relationships are imagined relationships that
viewers have with characters in media, whether they be talk show hosts and guests or characters in
films, plays, and so on.
The third report also deals with parasocial relationships, but in the context of interactive TV
movies. The problem which Schramm and Schlütz tackle is whether an interactive mode of TV
reception, enabling the viewer to influence both the narrative and the film characters, influences the
development of parasocial relationships between viewers and protagonists.
The last two reports also concentrate on interactive media. Klimmt and Vorderer explore the
attractiveness of Lara Croft, probably the most popular computer and video game character. Again
parasocial interactions and relationships seem to be the central dimension to explain this
phenomenon. Finally, Knobloch and Hartmann seek to distinguish genres of computer and video
games based on the perception of users.
Recent Developments in Research on Media Entertainment
Peter Vorderer
Entertainment is clearly one of the most important research objects of literature and media
studies. A growing number of readers, listeners, and viewers are spending more and more time on
"being entertained". Technological advances are utilized for new entertainment applications, while
"old" formats (e.g., radio, tv) are trying to preserve their entertaining qualities. It is obvious, that
"to entertain" is a goal of numerous media and that "to be entertained" is the goal of vast media
audiences.
But what do in the perspective of psychology and the study of literature media do to
entertain their audiences, and what do audiences do to be entertained? What kind of media content
is considered to be "entertaining, and what psychological processes cause the perception of "being
entertained"?
Finally, today's central development of entertainment, interactivity, is illustrated. In contrast
to traditional entertaining formats, interactive entertainment invites "users" to actively participate in
media content instead of passively witnessing it. This recursive process leads to transformations in
media content. Resulting research demands and perspectives are discussed.
Television as Communicative Action
Sabine Trepte & Sina Zapfe
Television becomes an increasingly socializing institution aside from family, peers, and
other communities; an institution that is not only entertaining or delivering information but rather a
platform of communication. Being a part of day- to- day interaction, television offers psychological
orientation on any kind of topic. It helps people in managing their day-to-day life and allows them
to construct their self-concepts. This kind of interaction with television is sought out by the
audience. Apart from ritualized television watching, there is an active, instrumental kind of viewing.
The viewer's associated aims or expectations vary from problem solving to the construction of
identity.
Two empirical studies were conducted to examine how these expectations are met in daily
talk shows. The daily talk show is a very successful genre in Germany: fourteen different shows are
telecast per day on similar topics, including, relationships, beauty, and personal problems. The first
investigation is based on survey data with a sample of young persons. We examine the extent to
which the interest in certain topics is a reaction to immediate personal problems. It turns out that
teenagers use daily talk shows to solve their problems. The second study addressed the meaning
and importance of participating in daily talk shows as a guest. Sixty-six semi-structured interviews
were conducted. The results revealed that, for viewers who would like to visit a daily talk show as a
guest, the construction of the self is one of the main motives. They see television in general, and
especially the daily talk shows, as an important platform for communication.
Para-social Relationships with TV Talk Show Hosts
Wiebke Sudhoff & Sabine Trepte
Daily talk shows are dominated by their hosts far more than other TV shows like game
shows. The show is named after the host, often only after the first name to enhance intimacy
between the host, the talk show guests, and the audience at home. There is empirical evidence that
for many viewers, the host represents the core of the show. He or she leads the viewer through the
endless stream of problems the guests are talking about. Certain characteristics of German daily
talk shows, like authenticity, emotionalism, and personalism, lead to "intimacy at a distance".
Both the host's dominant role and the shows' intimate character make viewers feel closer
to the hosts and develop para-social relationships. Besides different para-social relationships, TV
viewers watch talk shows for various reasons; some use the shows to entertain themselves, others
seek information.
An interaction between para-social relationships and viewing motives provides evidence for
the existence of different viewing patterns among the viewers. Some viewers feel like they are
friends with a host, whereas others see the host as an anchor in a news program. Our study
investigates these patterns. Furthermore, we study the perceived characteristics of hosts and
different concepts of the shows.
Parasocial Interactions with Film Characters in Interactive TV-drama
Holger Schramm & Daniela Schluetz
First described by Horton and Wohl (1956), parasocial interactions (PSI) between
recipients and protagonists are typical effects of exposure to media contents. Television in
particular, with its audio-visual quality, meets the requirements for developing PSI. So PSI is not
only prototypical for television and its entertaining programs, but may be the most important
condition for feeling entertained by TV (Vorderer, 1998).
Regarding the former traditional mode of TV reception, PSI processes were highly
determined by the structure of the media content or concerning narratives by the way the story
was told and the protagonist was presented. It is obvious that a new interactive mode of TV
reception, enabling the viewer to influence both the narrative and the protagonists, can create radical
new possibilities for PSI.
To prove the effect of interactive narratives regarding PSI, an experiment was conducted
with 427 persons, aged between 14 and 49 years, who watched a 30-minute TV-drama that differed
according to the degree of possible interventions. PSI was measured in terms of socio-emotional
variables like empathy, suspense, and involvement. The results show negative effects of interactivity
on the development of PSI and indicate that people prefer the traditional passive mode of reception
when they are watching entertaining, involving, or emotional stories in TV.
22. Symposium
HOW LITERATURE ENTERS LIFE
Els Andringa
Modern literary theory regularly separates literary texts and the literary system from the
"reality" of daily life. The concepts of autonomy ("interesseloses Wohlgefallen"), polyvalence, and
fictionality have been articulated in ways that diminish or even exclude the pragmatic functions of
literary reading. However, the condemnation and censorship of literary works based on political,
religious, or ethical arguments are reminders that the literary system is not independent of other
societal systems. Rather, literary reading is embedded within the broader social discourse, and
modern media regularly blur the boundaries between fiction and reality. It is hardly possible to read
a literary text without participating in an encounter between aspects of the fictional world and the
reader's life-world. But what are the forms of this encounter, and how does literature influence a
reader's position within the broader discourse? This symposium shows from different research
perspectives how "literature enters life".
Literature as a Spur to Collective Action
Elizabeth Long
In this contribution I will contrast two periods in women's reading groups from American
history. In the 19th century, these book clubs led women into various forms of reformist collective
action. In the 20th century, such has not been the case. I analyze this difference in "effects" in
relation to shifts in women's position in regard to both citizenship and education, as well as to shifts
in the institution of literature, including the cultural mission of literature as it was formulated by
critics and educators in the 19th century.
Reading Expressively Through "tears of light"
David S. Miall & Don Kuiken
Using systematic phenomenological methods (cf. Sikora, Kuiken, & Miall, 1998), we have
identified a distinctive mode of reading through which literary texts, on occasion, attain expressive
depth. Through this mode of reading, (1) an emergent affective theme is progressively transformed;
(2) these transformations occur through synaesthetic engagement with textually grounded imagery;
and (3) readers become implicated in the existential concerns embodied in the text. Readers report
that this kind of reading precipitates increased sensitivity to aspects of their lives that they usually
ignore. Although instigated by readers' engagement with stylistic features of the text (cf. Miall &
Kuiken, 1999), reading with expressive depth is not wholly determined by such features. Instead,
readers' life circumstances moderate the self-implicating and transformative effects of literary
reading. Some research indicates that these moderating circumstances are dispositions, i.e., stable
reader orientations. But dispositional accounts of expressive reading are vulnerable to the social
constructionist critique. The ideology of the "expressive depth" may seem an historically and
culturally relative set of conventions by which readers "discover" a text's illusory capacity to
cultivate certain sensitivities. To counter this critique, it is important to identify life circumstances
within which expressive depth "naturally" occurs through literary reading. To this end, we have
undertaken studies demonstrating that the existential contingencies associated with bereavement
provide conditions within which the narrative imagination, made manifest in dreams as well as
literary reading, attains expressive depth. We will review research, some presented for the first time,
articulating the circumstances that enable literary reading to penetrate the life world.
Reading the Culture
Sara Davis
Feminists have shown a strong interest in the effect that popular culture has on the
perspective of women. Of particular interest has been an examination of the impact of romance
novels. The enduring popularity of these books has been an enigma to many women's studies
scholars and several explanatory theories have been offered. Because of this interest, these book
have frequently been given a reading in women's studies classes although neglected in the literature
classroom. When read as part of a women's studies class, the books are analyzed not as literature
per se, but in terms of how they affect the women who read them. Pedagogically, students are
encouraged to consider their reaction to the books, and to move from there to an analysis of what
romance novels are likely to mean to women readers. In this presentation I will look first at
competing explanations for the almost addictive popularity of these books. I will then describe their
impact on a class of undergraduate college students.
The Fiction of the Reality of Fiction
Els Andringa
The media play an important role in the modern literary system. Part of the discourse related
to fiction is embedded in the newspapers and in radio and television broadcasts. Apart from the
traditional reviews, literature is mediated to the public in interviews with and documentary films
about authors, discussion panels and events connected to cultural prizes. One of the consequences
is that the boundaries between fiction and "reality" such as the life of the authors, opinions about
ethical and political questions, or historic events, become blurred more and more. Fiction seems to
enter reality, but also reality seems to enter fiction. To demonstrate this effect, I will show and
analyze a section from a documentary film in which the author Norman Mailer presents and
comments the recent history of the United States in relation to his own development as a writer or,
the other way around, his own development in relation to American history.
23. Paper Session
READING PROCESSES: V
Literary Research in Complex Models:
Methodological and Practical Considerations
Sibylle Moser
Recent discussions in the field of constructivist literary theory have emphasized the complex
character of literary communication from the angle of systems theory (Groeben, 1995). The major
fields of empirical research traditionally focussed on processes of literary reception from a
psychological point of view. In contrast, proposals like S. J. Schmidt's model of literature as a
self-organizing system of media, culture, cognition, and communication (Schmidt, 1994) suggest a
need for more complex research designs. Thus, literary communication can be observed
simultaneously according to constructive processes such as 1) cognitive schemata (processes of
learning and perception), 2) social conventions (processes of socialization), 3) cultural distinctions
(programs which result in the application of aesthetic norms and values) and 4) media conditions
(e.g. printed versus digital writing).
The paper will, therefore, outline different aspects of a research design which accounts for
the complexity of the observed phenomena with the complexity of its research strategies. I will
focus on the development of ontological and operational knowledge (sensu Rusch) about literary
action in the above mentioned four dimensions. Guided by a process-oriented constructivist attitude,
my key question does not concern literature as a given fact, but how people develop individual and
intersubjectively accepted notions of literature on the level of cognition, communication, media and
culture. A detailed methodological discussion will show that the observation of different systemic
processes calls for the consideration of different dimensions of reflexivity in the research field.
Groeben's differentiation of "Handeln", "Tun" and "Verhalten" (Groeben 1986) will serve to
distinguish between different degrees of reflexivity of human behaviour. To avoid methodological
abstraction I will, by way of exemple, introduce one method of empirical literary research in each
dimension of the outlined model, and draw the attention to the remaining problem of how data from
the four dimensions can be related in a methodologically controlled way in order to give an
adequate explanation of the phenomena in question.
Textual Typology: A Study of Interruptions in the
Linearity of the Act of Reading
Aldo Nemesio
This paper describes an experiment that studied differences in text processing when reading
different types of texts. Eight texts were used: five novels (examples of realist, thriller, fantastic,
stream of consciousness, and experimental narrative, respectively) and three essays (history,
philosophy, and music). The experiment examined interruptions in the act of reading the beginnings
of the eight texts with the assumption that interruptions in the linearity of the act of reading may
signal a change in cognitive operations of text processing. The subjects were asked to read one of
the eight texts, recording their reading pauses, and later to specify the reasons for their pause marks,
giving a short description of the contents of their pauses. Finally they were given an appreciation
question. The test was not disruptive, since the only operation the subjects had to perform while
reading consisted in making a few marks on the pages. Results give information on pause
distribution, pause regularity, and text appreciation in relation to the different texts. The test also
shows changes in readers' behaviour while reading different parts of the same text.
Literary Expertise and Analogical Reasoning at
Multiple Levels of Text Description
Barbara Graves
This paper investigates the analogical reasoning of six literary academics and writers while
describing a fictional narrative. Cognitive research on expertise suggests that experts structure and
use information differently from those who are less expert and that these differences are linked not
only to differences in prior domain knowledge but also to the way that their knowledge is
organized. This analysis of the reasoning patterns in the text descriptions of literary experts
focuses on analogical reasoning and contributes to our understanding of how expert readers of
literature integrate information from the text with their world and literary knowledge as they
construct a problem or develop a theme. The model of reasoning patterns applied to readers'
text-description protocols specified a semantic network with unit nodes based on reasoning
operations (claim, hypothesis, analogy, expectation, question, evaluation, and meta-statement) linked
by relations (condition, elaboration, and reiteration). In this way, it was possible to examine not
only the types of reasoning operations undertaken by readers, but also the structure, coherence, and
scope of their reasoning.
While the results of the quantitative analysis reveal that expert readers generated relatively
few analogies, the qualitative analyses suggest that regardless of the low frequencies, analogies
played an important role in expert readers' literary text descriptions. The findings reveal that
analogical comparisons may be constructed at any of the multiple levels of the text descriptions, i.e.,
the linguistic, propositional, or conceptual frame descriptions. In some cases, the analogical
comparisons were signaled explicitly by the text, while in other cases the analogies were particular
to individual readers and were generated from world knowledge. In addition, these expert readers
generated analogical comparisons in relation to the communicative context which includes a model
of the author. Such inter-textual references appear as an important vehicle for elaborating
knowledge schemas which served to frame their descriptions of the text. In this way these
elaborated references served as a form of data generation and management for expert readers.
While providing a means of articulating large amounts of connected information, the analogical
comparisons also permitted expert readers to work with multiple interpretive possibilities.
The Processing of Opaque Poetic Texts: Mechanisms of Selection
Iris Yaron
Les poèmes opaques posent une question au chercheur qui s'intéresse au lecteur: des tels
poèmes, violant les normes de la communication (ordinaire), comment sont-ils traités par le
destinataire? Perturbabt les procédures de la compréhension, le poème opaque déclencherait des
mécanismes de traitement alternatifs. L'article avance deux arguments entrectoisés: si le facteur de
la linéarité perd de son importance, celui de l'intelligibilité prend une importance accrue. Je
soutiens, en effet, que dans la réception du poème opaque, une opposition se dessine entre
matériaux inteligibles (qui suite à la difficulté deviennent saillants) et matériaux négligeables. Ces
derniers ne sont pas concrétisées par le récepteur même aux stades avancés du traitement. Deux
études empiriques, fondées sur la tâche du rappel, ont été mené. Les résultats obtenus, indiquent une
assimilation non séquentielle du poème opaque, orientée principalement vers les éléments
proéminents du poème et le déclenchement de mecanismes de sélection. Le traitement d'un poème
opaque a été comparé à celui d'un poème non difficile. Les résultats concernant ce dernier mettent
en évidence les particularités du traitement du poème opaque. Ils permettent également de vérifier
des questions ayant trait à l'activité de recherche et de construction dans le traitement du poème
opaque, à la production des inférences et à la restitution (trop) exacte de ses composantes.
23a. Symposium
INDIAN WRITING IN ENGLISH IN GLOBAL CONTEXTS
Ashok Sachdeva
Literature enlightens mind and soul irrespective of its medium of expression. Though
Hindi has been the lingua-franca of India, the country produced stalwarts who have significantly
contributed to the development of literature written in English. Most prominent amongst them
today are R. N. Tagore, and many others such as A. K. Ramanujan, Jayant Mahapatra, O. P.
Bhatnagar, Shiv. K. Kumar, Nissim Ezekiel, Kamla Das, among others. Still, one should not lose
sight of mysticism imbibed from the traditional school of Indian poetry, including Kabir. They all
hit at the basic issue -- human weakness about the code of conduct and behaviour, reiterating a deep
faith inhumanity and human values. Such an approach put Indian literary figures at par with the
classical masters, at the same time serving as a bridge between the East and West. Thus, literature of
all the world seem to have common frontiers and issues to deal with, along with similar solutions.
The session attempts to probe and analyse common issues and solutions from a comparative
perspective.
Tagore's "Binodoni"
Yashpal Vyas
The beginning of the 20th century marks in Indian fiction of the birth of the modern novel, an
achievement largely the work of Rabindranath Tagore and heralded by his "Chokher Bali"
serialized in the journal Bangadarshan in 1901 and published in book form in 1903. The historical
importance of this novel has been suggested in diverse critical assessments as; a departure from the
historical romances of Bankimchandra Chatterji, an inspiration for the work of Saratchandra
Chatterji, a sensitive record of Indian society in transition, notably the resurgence of the middle
class and the gradual disappearance of the feudal aristocracy, the first Indian all-round
psychological novel, and a masterly analysis of the revolt of the individual against the domination of
the large family. Binodini is hailed as the first woman in modern Indian fiction to revolt against the
moral code, and is cited as the best example of Tagores frank and sympathetic acceptance of the
kinship between love and sex. As rightly pointed out by S. K. Banergy, Binodini is not the
portrayal of an obsession with impure passions or an insistence on the unpurged urge of sexual-
impulse as the key fact of the mystery of human life. The present study proposes to reexamine
Binodini's image free from the overtones of social reform and the claims of a modern tone based
on a clinical diagnosis of murky passions. Binodini is shown to be neither a typical widow steeped
in pathos, nor a martyr renouncing her right for love, but as an intensely human individual who
emerges as a better person from the havoc unwittingly created by her understandably human lapses.
Literature, Society, and Governance
(The Poetry of Kabir Das in Indian Context)
S. K. Bhatt
India is a land of wonders-vivid people with illuminating literature! It has a continuous
cultural tradition initiated in the encyclopaedic Vedic literature survived with the epic one-the
Mahabharata and the Ramayana, supperadded by the Arthasastra and Smrati Schools and enriched
even in the 20th century by M.K. Gandhi's "My Experiments with Truth", all exclaiming the lofty
ideals in life like, "God lead us from ignorance to knowledge"; "Let noble thought come to us
from all sides"; "The world is one family"; and "Live and let live". Thus such an enlightened
Indian tradition has lit the mind and soul of humanity in the world.
Indian society, thus with widened horizons, grew and nation developed. In this
unprecedented process of social growth and national development, the Indian society, many a times,
underwent several turmoils, posing imminent threats to the age old spirit of concord and harmony.
In the foggy middle ages, the regimented ritualism promoted by the priests and maulavis, further
deepened the socio-politico-economic conflict by widening the gap between light and darkness,
knowledge and ignorance, vice and virtue, and the rich and the poor. Here when the Kings and
Courtiers failed to restore in society the laws of governance, the Saint-Poets of Medieval India, like
Kabir (in 15th century) through simple and popular poetic sayings, succeeded in establishing peace
and harmony in the country.
Kabir wrote what he saw and experienced during his times, and like a Doctor while
diagnosing the prevailing socio-politic evils of the society, prescribed Hindu-Muslim unity as its
remedy proscribing the hallow rituals and unmeaningful mode of worship for both-the Hindus and
the Hindus. His poetic expressions, though simple but stout, representing the age-old assimilated
wits and wisdom, derived from the above mentioned literary traditions, continue serving as Becon
light for the 20th century humanity, which largely suffers from conflict and social disharmony.
Being himself a weaver by profession, Kabir successfully expounded in his poetry, the
science and art of weaving social harmony, peace and concord among all the sections of divergent
caste, creed and culture by propounding an ideal code of conduct like, "The best way to serve the
Creator is to serve His creation:; "The path to service to God lies through service to humanity";
"Satguru (God) is a giver and not a beggar"; and "Those who run after wealth..... are not true
devotees". His poetry has left behind for us a poser to ponder over; "If you say God dwells only
in the mosque or He dwells in an idol, then who dwells in the rest of the world? It leaves a message
for humanity through this couplet:
Death after death the world dies,
But no one knows how to die;
Who knows how to die, O Kabir
Never faces death again.
A.G., p.1366:29
Recent Indo Anglian Poetry: An Empirical Survey
Ashok Sachdeva
Roger Iredele, an Englishman and cultural emissary from England to India places the
modern Indian in English in the context of International standards and comments "...it is
refreshing to turn to Indian poetry written in English and to find in it a freshness and variety that
reflects the remarkable diversity and vigour of the culture from which it stems". The observation is
significant for it points out at least three salient characteristics of the recent Indian poetry in
English : (i) it represents a significant break with earlier poetic and cultural sensibility, (ii)
transcending the pseudo spiritual preoccupations of earlier phase, it has shifted the poetic quest
inward to the individual, and (iii) the resultant sensibility is fiercely responsive to the
socio-politico-cultural reality.
Indo-Anglian poetry has reached a certain height and depth today and reflects the culture
and literature before the world. Nissim Ezekiel, A.K.Ramanujun, Jayant Mahapatra, R. Parthasarthi,
Kamala Das, Keki-N Daruwala and Pritish Nandi have added new dimensions to the Indo-Anglian
poetry both in themes and styles and the intensity of experience and sincerity of purpose. New
voices are heard sweetly and new promises are made by the poets like Adil Jassuwala, Arun
Khalokar, A.K. Merhotra, O.P. Bhatnagar and many others.
The present paper seeks to examine and analyse the charm and beauty of the Indo- Anglian
poetry with special reference to the textdata based empirical survey of select poems by O.P.
Bhatnagar,and Shiv K.Kumar and, if possible those of Nissim Ezekiel, K.V. Suryanaranyan
Murthy, Jayant Mahapatra, R. Parthasarthe, A.K. Ramanujan and Kamla Das. There is a tryst with
the cosmos in K.V. Suryanarayana Murthi who imparts a cosmic sweep and vision to his poetry.
Mahapatra's. The False Start shows life against ruins life-giving spirit of the poems as a whole in
the face of disaster, decay and death. A. K. Ramanujan's confessional poetry abandons the
modernistic devices of personae, anonymity, masks, and indirection with the tendency to place the
literal self more at the centre. O.P. Bhatnagar's political and protest poetry focuses on the breadth
of his experience and the solemnity of his involvement in the affairs of life in an ironical manner.
Shiv K. Kumar's free poetry grapples with mute confession and voiceless wailings and complex
problems of an individual today. The paper also endeavors to draw comparisons and parallels with
Canadian literature.
24. Symposium
ENTERTAINING MEDIA: II
Sex Symbol Tech Toy?
Exploring the Attractiveness of Lara Croft
Christoph Klimmt & Peter Vorderer
Computer and video games have become a widely spread entertainment medium. The
technical development is extremely fast, and the amount of money and time spent on interactive
games by the users is rising continously. In spite of that, communication science is still discovering
computer games as a research topic. While a considerable number of studies have been conducted
on the effects of violent video games, almost no research has dealt with how players experience
video games in general.
Lara Croft (Tomb Raider" series) is probably the most popular video game character in
America and Europe. The study presented has investigated the question why this character is so
popular among so many players. Parasocial interaction and play theory offer a useful framework to
analyse this attraction phenomenon. Parasocial interaction theory expects that the game character is
perceived by the user as a somehow real person with whom one can socially interact. According to
this model, the player is fascinated by the character because it functions as an object of social
cognition, similar to a television character. Various dimensions of para-social interaction, such as
confidence, passion, or sociability can be differentiated.
Play theory comprises additional factors that can explain the attractivity of computer game
characters. According to play theory, Lara Croft and her related characters are ideal because they are
extremely realistic and fully reactive to user commands. Moreover, they open up numerous action
opportunities to the player. These action possibilites make an interesting "toy" out of Lara Croft
and are expected to be another reason of Lara Croft´s attractiveness.
Senders of fan mail to Lara Croft were asked to fill in a questionnaire that embraced various
dimensions of parasocial interaction and play theory. Factor analysis was used to uncover factors
relevant for experiencing Lara Croft as fascinating. Implications for the general attractiveness of
interactive entertainment are discussed.
Genres of Interactive Media Entertainment
Theoretical Considerations and Users' Perceptions
Silvia Knobloch & Tilo Hartmann
Computer and video games have become a common way of media use. "Interactive
entertainment has graduated to mass medium status" (NUA, 1998) as more and not only juvenile
users spend a considerable amount of time and money on the virtual playground. For descriptions
and selections of computer games, their categorizations in genres have achieved the same
importance as genres have for the landscape of literature and films. Magazines and web-sites about
computer games refer as a matter of course to these genres, even though the criteria of ranging a
game are very ambiguous. But research about this new form of media 'reception' requires proper
labelling, as users' experiences differ fundamentally according to the subtypes of computer games.
What key elements should be taken into account for this purpose? We address this problem from a
theoretical and an empirical perspective.
While the assignment of linear media like books or films to genres are already often
difficult, classifying non-linear computer games raise even more questions. As users create the
story-line mostly by their own actions, users' perceptions are indispensable for an adequate
classification of computer games. Several concepts of computer game categorizations of scholars
and professionals will be presented. Results of a survey with 1125 heavy gamers will contrast these
theoretical concepts with an empirical structure of computer games that bases on perceptions of
users.
25. Paper Session
CHANGES IN RECEPTION BEHAVIOUR AND PREFERENCES
Television Viewing Behavior of Specific Reader Types 1975-1995
Kees van Rees & Koen van Eijck
In this paper, we use data from the 1975 and 1995 Dutch Time Budget Surveys (N=1200 &
N=3300) to analyze the relationship between television viewing and reading behavior, and the
changes in this relationship over time. The central question of the paper is: How do specific reader
types differ in their television viewing behavior? This question is answered by (i) using latent class
analysis to identify the set of mutually exclusive latent classes of readers and (ii) estimating the
probability that each reader type will display a specific kind of content-related television viewing
behavior. Types of print media (newspapers and consumer magazines) and television programs are
differentiated by referring to the extent to which they each focus on kinds of information or
entertainment or both. Five reader types were identified according to how each specifically
combines various reading items: Entertainment readers, information readers, regional readers, non
readers and 'omnivores'. Analysis of television viewing behavior shows the existence of five
audience segments with clearly distinct background characteristics. The results give empirical
substance to the notions of media orientation and audience segmentation; they document the overall
decline in reading. The approach makes it possible to critically consider current use of labels such
as 'omnivorousness'.
Heterogeneity in Reading Behavior: Changes Between 1975 and 1995
Marc Verboord
In various reports since the 1970's changes in the amount of reading behaviour in The
Netherlands are documented. The time spent on reading has declined between 1975 and 1995. This
holds for each of the three most important printmedia: magazines, newspapers,and books. Within
these mediatypes, further differentiations are possible, as has been done for magazines and
newspapers, but not for books until now.
Describing the trends in the reading of a variety of booktypes is the first goal of this paper.
A second step will be the investigation of the way these booktypes are combined on an individual
level, and what changes can be seen through time in these combinations. The individual choices that
are made out of the booksupply will be categorized by booktype, scaled by the literary prestige that
these booktypes represent, and finally cumulated to a pattern of choices.
The choice pattern is emphaticly the research object. Although research in cultural
participation usually shows a strong positive correlation between the complexity and prestige of the
cultural activity on the one hand, and the intellectual capacity en social status of the participant on
the other hand, there are reasons to assume that this relation has gotten weaker through time.
The influence of the educational level on the amount of reading has decreased. To a great
extent, this is the result of the increase of the number of students in higher forms of education.
Highly educated people with low educated parents turn out to be less culturally active as a result of
the lack of a socialization stimulus. At the same time, the educational system itself has altered in the
course of time because of the new students with other backgrounds.
Trends in society as leisure time growing scarce, the cultural domain getting more
commercial, and borders between high-, middle- and low-brow culture slowly fading away, give rise
to expectations that high- and low-art will be increasingly mixed together, especially by those who
already consume more than average. Peterson (1992) talks in this regard about the existence of
'omnivore-patterns.' Omnivores distinguish themselves by a lot of consumption and a wide variety
of preferences within this consumption.
Criticism has been put forward on Peterson's measurement of omnivore-behaviour because
of its aggregated nature (Van Eijck, 1998). It was suggested to use latent class analysis, which could
characterize persons in their behavioral patterns on an individual level (Van Rees, Vermunt &
Verboord 1999). A disadvantage of this measurement procedure, however, is that persons are
labelled as either omnivore or non-omnivore without room for gradual differences.
In this paper a new way of measuring will be presented for the heterogenity of reading
behaviour. This procedure allows calculating the gradual differences on an individual level.
A Systematic Content Analysis of Eight Decades of Best-selling Mystery Novels
Jennings Bryant, Lisa Mullikin & J. Alison Bryant
A sample of 96 best-selling mystery novelsa dozen from each decade of the 1920s
through the 1990swas subjected to a systematic, page-by-page content analysis. In order to
assess stable and dynamic features of this popular fictional genre, numerous different elements
were systematically examined. Included were gender and nationality of the author, setting and
location of the novel, formula and sub-formula, the type of crime(s) committed, the means and
motivation for the crime, the characteristics of the principle characters (heroes, villains, sidekicks,
victims, etc.), when and how clues were employed, the nature and means of vindication, and a matrix
of character relationships. The focal point of the investigation was a timeline on which the plot and
action of the novels were determined as part of a stochastic model.
The data are still being analyzed, but several aspects of the analysis will be completed in
time for presentation at IGEL2000. Because fine detail and complex relationships are better
understood in other presentation formats, the conference presentation will focus on more macro
analytic aspects of the investigation. Essentially we will present a profile of the evolution of the
mystery novel throughout its golden age, emphasizing major trends revealed by the normative data
from our investigation. Examples and excerpts from the best-selling mystery novels of the past 80
years will be utilized to bring life to the statistical profile.
Changes in Cultural Repertoires: Overlaps Between the
Choices Made by Different Groups of Movie-goers
Dorothee Verdaasdonk
Over the last years, cultural repertoires have undergone substantial changes. In the sixties
and seventies, researchers found that differences in socio-economic characteristics were good
predictors of differences in cultural consumption (Bourdieu 1979). Nowadays, socio-economic
differences seem to have less and less impact on differences in cultural participation (Peterson &
Simkus, 1997). The increase of the level of education of the population in Western countries has
led to a substantial growth in size of the public for culture. This growth, in turn, has made cultural
producers aware of the fact that the supply of cultural goods has to cater for widely diverging tastes.
At the same time, a loss of hierarchy seem to have occurred within in the field of the arts.
Traditionally, judges of new productions ranked these according to their artistic quality. There was
general agreement on the standards which should be applied and on the `great' achievements against
which new productions had to be weighed. Gradually, the framework within which cultural goods
are perceived and judged has become more pluralistic. Not only artistic merit, but also entertainment
value are aspects judges and consumers have come to appraise in cultural products. The distinction
between `high' and `low' culture has lost much of its significance. Our inquiry looks into factors
other than socio-economic characteristics that might account for participation in culture focuses on
movie-goers. Our data are drawn from a survey of 805 visitors to four movie theaters in Amsterdam
during May and June 1999. Our hypothesis is that the channels used for acquiring information
about movies to be seen, extant patterns of movie-going, preferences for specific types of movies
and, above all, the cycles in which theaters program different categories of movies have strong
impact on attendance. Some cycles of programming are such that a large audience is attracted,
comprising spectators with very different socio-economic characteristics. Other cycles attract
smaller groups of viewers whose socio-economic characteristics are more homogenous. However,
their pattern of movie-going, exemplified by their patronage of particular theaters, the reasons for
seeing movies and the aspects of movies they think important, and the repertoire of other cultural
activities they engage in, are supposed to have greater explanatory value of the choices they make
than their socio-economic characteristics - perhaps with the exception of age.
26. Paper Session
DISCUSSION OF SPECIFIC TEXTS
"The Lord Will Whistle for the Fly": Allegory, Allusion, and Parable as Social and
Cultural Contexts in Joyce Carol Oates' "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?"
Robert Branda
Joyce Carol Oates' familiar story "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?" holds
an honored place in the canon of contemporary fiction because it resonates with universal themes
like the passage from innocence to experience, while at the same time illuminating complicated
social and cultural influences. For example, Oates' story resonates with the shock and titillation,
the thrill of bizarre violence that springs from today's tabloid media. The story of Arnold Friend
and Connie documents a tale of stalker and victim reminiscent of real-world crime stories from
Charles Manson to Spur Posse. Oates' story engrosses readers with its portrait of a pathological
personality preying upon a compliant victim thus illuminating a significant insight from feminist
criticism. It offers the premonition that predictable, protected lives can be shattered in a moment of
random threat and perverse attack.
Although the story's psychological realism rivets attention, Oates' story also rests on a
complex architecture of traditional literary forms like allegory, allusion, and parable, which gain
synergy when combined with the author's powerful psychological realism. In fact, the story's
complexity is often given short shrift because Arnold Friend, a character based on a real life
Manson-type serial killer, diverts attention from the fact that Oates' story transforms the
documentary realism that inspired the tale into a profound morality tale illustrating Oates' religious
imagination and how that imagination throws light on its social and contemporary milieu. As a
complex morality, Oates' story is rooted in Biblical literature, the folk tales of the Brothers Grimm,
and the headlines of tabloid journalism. The story's most memorable character, Arnold Friend, is a
chimera of Connie's fantasy world equally inspired by Hollywood icons like Marlon Brando and
James Dean, by Bob Dylan's rock lyrics, and by the mall culture of California's "Valley Girls"
who perpetually search for beguiling boy-toys. Little wonder that Oates' story was easily adapted
into a compelling cinematic version titled Smooth Talk starring Laura Dern and Treat Williams.
This fusion of literary, social, and cultural forces will require detailed explication.
Stratified Reading: Gilles Deleuze on D. H. Lawrences's ''Apocalypse"
Mary Bryden
The act of reading is an organic one, requiring the application of living brain processes to
text. The consequent and dependent activity of commentary continually demonstrates that response
is as multiform as the number of responders. This complexity is enhanced when the chain of
reading is further extended, when commentaries are themselves commented upon, and when texts
are read through the intervening filter of other writers.
This paper takes as a case study the example of Gilles Deleuze's commentary (in the form
of a preface) upon D. H. Lawrence's own commentary upon the Book of Apocalypse. Further
complexity is lent to the commentatorial event by two factors. First, Deleuze applies the writing of
Nietzsche (notably, 'The Ante-Christ') to his reading of Lawrence. Second, the biblical 'Apocalypse'
is, as Lawrence himself points out, attributable to no single writer. Its stratified texture is a
composite of layers, echoings, and transformations. It appears as an adaptation of pagan and
mythological traditions, assembled in particular historical circumstances, and angled towards a
particular audience - that of a struggling early Christian community. As Lawrence affirms
elsewhere: 'An Apocalypse has, must have, is intended to have various levels or layers of strata of
meaning'.
This paper will trace Deleuze's analysis of Lawrence with reference to both the Book of
Apocalypse (Revelation) and to Nietzsche. It will demonstrate that, although Deleuze summarises in
his commentary many key points made by Lawrence, he also creates a further superstratum of his
own, in emphasising notions of flux and transition, in ways which derive more obviously from
Deleuze's own writing (particularly, with Guattari, in 'Mille Plateaux') than from that of Lawrence.
This results in a softening of Lawrence's recurrently dualist perspective, and a subtle transportation
of his material into a more properly Deleuzian frame of reference.
Pre-adolescent Youth and Adult Interpretations of J.k. Rowling's
"Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone"
Marilyn Draheim
Three novels by J. K. Rowling based on an appealing character, Harry Potter, have been
internationally successful as works of imaginative fiction intended for pre-adolescent readers, ages
9-12. The character's whimsical adventures and self-discovery as well as the author's witty writing
have appealed to adult readers. This study examines the bases for which this book has wide-spread
appeal for children and adults. The study examines fifth grade children's interpretations of
Rowling's first novel, "Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone". A comparison group of adult
participants from an on-going book discussion group will also respond to the novel. First, they will
participate in personal responses to the novel, in particular, to the character, his adventures, and the
organization of the novel. Second, the subjects will participate in a book discussion group for
mediated discussion of the novel, the protagonist, and the organization of the novel. The appeal of
the Harry Potter adventures may be explained by notions of the suspension of disbelief and
multiple levels of meaning as suggested by Fiske's theory of polysemous messages. Also,
Vygotskian, social constructionist, and sociocultural theories will provide a base for comparison of
the appeal of the novel for children and adult readers by suggesting that learning and the making of
meaning is mediated by others. Personal responses and group-mediated responses will provide
points of commonality and differences in the interpretations of the novel by youth and adult
readers. The above theories will provide the bases.
Visual Rhetoric in Margaret Atwood's "Alias Grace"
Michelle Gadpaille
Is Grace Marks guilty of murder, or not guilty for extenuating psychological reasons?
These are the question posed by Alias Grace and not ultimately answered, but suspended in the
text's riddling,
postmodern narrative.
Atwood complicates the debate by providing each chapter of the novel with pictorial
epigraphs which offer guidance to the reader attuned to the visual rhetoric of the sub-culture of
quilting. The traditional quilt block patterns, appearing as decorative chapter-heads and as chapter
titles (for example, Snake Fence, Jagged Edge, Tree of Paradise), constitute a separate trope system,
employing metaphor, allusion, metonymy, and other figures of speech to construct an interpretive
guide to the novel's mysteries.
This paper will decode the symbolism of the quilt blocks and their titles, consider the role of
the epigraphs as interpretive metatrope, and show Atwood's integration into historiographical
metafiction of a symbolic system from the cultural margin.
27.
Memorial Session for Steen Folke Larsen
Janos Laszlo
Steen Larsen was a founding member of IGEL; a fine scholar much loved by his
colleagues. In this session, some of Steen's colleagues and friends will talk about Steen and his
effect on their lives and work.
28. Invited Address
INTERACTIVITY AND INVOLVEMENT IN LARGE FORMAT DIGITAL CINEMA
Stacey Spiegel
This presentation will explore the interface between traditional story narrative in cinema and
contemporary video game technology. Immersion Studios has developed a digital technology
solution for the interaction of large format visuals and the participating audience. The involvement
of the audience in an unfolding story has its roots in various forms of theatrical presentation such
as laterna magika in Prague (first seen in Canada at Expo'67). From a visual perspective, cinerama
and circle vision extended the movie around the audience. In the next generation of cinematic
involvement, IMAX passed the audience through the window into the centre of the action. Each step
in the evolution of engaged-cinema enhanced the experience of virtual presence in the scene.
Over the last twenty years, computer technology has opened a new avenue in entertainment.
Electronic games are rapidly outpacing Hollywood cinema in capturing the attention of
contemporary youth culture. These games provide a sensory-rich environment accompanied by the
experience of control over outcomes. Participants can also identify with characters while
constructing the story line of the developing game. This sense of agency and experience of
involvement can make simulated games more appealing than watching "real" sports events over
which viewers have no control.
Immersion Studios combines the large format IMAX-style experience with the interactive
potential of computer games in a group setting. Using the latest in digital technology, individual
audience members can affect and control aspects of the story and its direction. There are three
forms of interactive participation; personal, interactive, and competitive. Each show integrates these
forms of interactivity in different combinations to heighten involvement and the entertainment
experience. The presentation at Immersion Studios will include the large format visual experience
(on a 24' X 72' screen) and a first-hand introduction to the various forms of interactive participation.
As the members of IGEL are expert in the analysis of narrative process, we will have an opportunity
for members of our creative staff to be in dialogue with them. The problems surrounding group
based interactive involvement will be at the core of the presentation and subsequent discussion.
PLEASE NOTE:
THIS EVENT WILL TAKE PLACE AT IMMERSION STUDIOS WHICH IS LOCATED
ON THE CANADIAN NATIONAL EXHIBITION (CNE) FAIRGROUNDS
BUSES WILL DEPART AT 6:15 pm AND RETURN AT 8:15 pm
29. Paper Session
ADVERTISING, NATURE, AND SCENT
Topping the Charts: Effects of Popular Music in Television Advertisements
Cynthia King
The use of Billboard Chart hits has become a popular strategy in television advertising. In
many cases, the music serves as the dominant audio, if not the only audio element in video-montage
style advertisements. This experimental study investigates the impact of this music on advertising
appeal and effectiveness.
Several factors are explored as potential mediators of music's effects including music
dominance, music familiarity, affect toward the music, relevance of music to the product or service,
and relevance of the music to the respondent's social group. Previous research suggests that liked
and relevant music should be most effective; however, no research has examined the related element
of music popularity or familiarity. Thus, an important question for this investigation is whether
music popularity or familiarity may have an impact separate or different from the appeal or
relevance of the music alone.
Several advertisements were manipulated and embedded in normal breaks of a television
program. Four different music types were substituted into the advertisements:Popular-relevant
music, popular-irrelevant music, unfamiliar-relevant music, and unfamiliar-irrelevant music. The ads
were further manipulated to create versions in which the music served as either the only audio
element or as background to extensive narration.
The impact of these factors was assessed through survey evaluations of the advertisements
and the products advertised administered after respondents had finished viewing the program.
Exploring the Meanings of Nature Through the Analysis of
Personal Stories and Responses to Advertisements
Anna Galeta & Gerald C. Cupchik
This paper reports three studies which explore the meanings of the term 'nature' through
content analysis of selected advertisements and narrative analysis. The first study was designed to
explore the representations of 'nature' in a sample of contemporary advertisements. Full-page colour
advertisements were selected to address three nature-related issues: (1) resource exploitation; (2)
wildlife preservation; and (3) recreational use of nature. The selection covers a wide range of
audiences and purposes. The advertisements were content-analysed, with the attention being paid to
immediate visual aspects of the advertisements, such as text-image relationships, image size in
relation to page size, manifest and latent contents, type of appeal, and so on. The second study
examined the relationship between pro-environmental motivations (ecocentric and anthropocentric),
the meaning of the term 'nature', and the participants' responses to selected advertisements.
Participants completed an attitude survey and rated each advertisement on its aesthetic appeal, as
well as its affective and connotative values. In the third study, participants were interviewed about
their childhood and adult experiences with nature, and the term 'nature' was explored in various
contexts. Participants also chose several advertisements from the sample given to them (same
categories as above) and talked about their understanding of 'nature' within the advertisements.
Participants related to the advertisements based on either: (1) experience with the object depicted,
(2) style of the ad, or (3) issue raised in the ad. Different advertisements evoked different modes of
reception. It remains to establish whether the modes of reception correlate with the categories of
advertisements, and whether other modes of reception will emerge.
The Scent of Literature
Krista Phillips, Gerald Cupchik, & Valorie Salimpoor
This study was conducted as part of a series of experiments on the role of odor in everyday
life. If the experience of images is a part of literary reception, then having subjects actually smell
odors while reading should modulate the experience of literary passages. Proust visits the
laboratory! Thirty-two subjects (16 male, 16 female), run individually, encountered 6 positive (e.g.,
fresh cut grass) and 6 negative (e.g., rotting leaves) odors prepared by the International Fragrances
and Flavours corporation. The odors were embedded in pellets and presented in white opaque plasic
containers. Subjects also read 8 excerpts (about 110 words each) from literary passages that we
have used during the past several years. These excerpts represented the combination of positive or
negative subject matter with positive or negative syle (with one replication).The 2 X 2 X 2 X 2
factorial design had one between-subjects variable, Gender, and three withins-subjects variables,
Odor (positive, negative), Subject Matter (positive, negative), and Style (positive, negative). The
combinations of individual odors, subject matter, and style were fully counterbalanced across
subjects. Subjects smelled four odors (2 positive and 2 negative) and rated them on five 7-point
scales. Then they smelled the assigned odor up to three times while reading each literary passage.
After finishing to read each passage, subjects rated the odor on six 7-point scales; pleasing,
soothing, energizing, number of evoked sensory images and feelings, and effect of the odor on
bringing the story to life. They then rated the story on eight 7-point scales such as, absorption in the
story, identification with the characters, imagine the scene, sense the plot, personally meaningful,
and nature of involvement.
Results showed that subject matter had an impact on the experience of the odors;
consistency between positive subject matter and positive odor enhanced images, feelings, and
brought the story to life. Inconsistency in the form of negative subject matter and positive odor was
confusing and reduced the experience of olfactory, visual, or auditory images. In a similar way,
positive style and positive odor fostered the experience of feelings, while positive style and negative
odors reduced the experience of feelings. The hedonic tone of the odor also modulated the
experience of the text. Subjects found it easier to imagine the scene when both odor and subject
matter were positive. There were also quite a number of effects involving gender and odor for
ratings of the passages. These findings underscore the importance of sensory imaginal processes
in literary reception.
30. Symposium
EVOLUTIONARY APPROACHES TO LITERATURE: I
David Miall & Willie van Peer
Evolution, Speciation, and Extinction of Artistic and Literary Styles
Colin Martindale
I have elsewhere proposed a theory of the history of art and literature patterned after
Darwin's theory of sexual or hedonic selection. Artists are under many selection pressures, but
most of these are not constant enough to produce evolutionary trends. For example, puritanical
liturature is not fit in licentious eras; licentious literature is not fit in puritanical eras. Thus, fitness
cannot explain aesthetic evolution as there are not consistent selection criteria. On the other hand, a
work of art in any tradition must always be new or different from all preceding works. Though the
pressure for novelty is weak, because it is consistent it ends up explaining around half of the
variance in any artistic tradition. In the case of poetry, let us define a style as an acceptable lexicon
of words and acceptable ways of combining them. In order to produce a novel work of art, one must
move toward a state of primordial cognition (concrete and reverie-like thought). Such thought leaves
its marks on the content of poetry. Within a given style, we should then expect more and more
evidence of primordial thought. Eventually, all possible word combinations with have been used.
This calls for a style change: simplifying the rules and using new words. This allows novelty or
unpredictability to increase at a cost of less primordial cognition. I have gathered a good bit of
evidence that novelty or unpredictability increases across time in any artistic tradition, whereas
evidence of primordial cognition oscillates.
Within a tradition, styles can become extinct because the relationship between novelty and
primordial cognition is an inverted-U one. Too much primordial cognition leads to diffuse and
holophrastic thought that decreases rather than increases unpredictability. Late English
metaphysical poetry is an illustration. Entire traditions can become extinct because all possible
styles and words have been used. Who reads modern poetry? Who listens to modern atonal
classical music? No one.
On the Origins of Style
Willie van Peer
A brief state of the art in stylistics leads to an appreciation of the strength and weaknesses
of current stylistic approaches. My own view is that progress has been made on a number of local
levels, where the power of text analysis has been greatly increased over the past 20 years. On a
more global level, however, where general models and theories of style are concerned, progress is
much less evident. I will propose that somehow or other we seem to have lost track of the more
general questions and that we urgently need to re-frame them again. As an example of what we
could do in this respect, I will argue in favour of an interdisciplinary approach that applies insights
and reasoning from the field of evolutionary psychology. One basic question that such an approach
might answer (or at least begin to look at in more detail) is the question of the origins of style, of
stylistic perception and sensitivity. Why, in other words, is it that human beings are able to
discriminate between different styles? I will argue that the answer to such questions may
meaningfully be related to the evolution of the species during the Pleistocene. I will extend and
partly reformulate hypotheses that have been advanced some decades ago and which I believe need
to be invigorated again. I also believe that such hypotheses and their investigation will cast light on
larger theoretical problems which haunt the discipline.
Lament and Liminality
Ellen Dissanayake
In a highly social primate like ourselves, the loss of a child, mate, or close friend through
death generally results in an emotional state of sadness or distress, called grief, often characterized
by weeping and mourning. In many human societies, from Northern Eurasia to the Mediterranean
to Highland New Guinea, the "natural" (innate) emotional response is transformed into a "cultural"
(learned) public performance, the lament. Mourners do not just weep uncontrollably, as might be
expected with intolerable loss, but structure their sobs into conventionalized, highly expressive
vocalizations. Just as laments occupy a liminal state between nature and culture, they exist
somewhere between song and speech, emotional speech and poetry, and -- since the lament is meant
to be acknowledged and even echoed by others - between private self-expression and public
occasion. Occurring widely, performed by both sexes, and sharing universal features, the lament
provides a fertile arena for raising questions and suggesting answers about the nature, origin, and
function of song and poetic language.
31. Paper Session
THE WRITING PROCESS: I
Writing Assessment Through the Lens of Literary Interpretation
Barbara Graves
As psychological and educational researchers have been extending their investigations of
complex cognition to include real-world contexts of performance, many have come to realize that
when trying to understand cognition as situated practice, the perspective of a single discipline is
simply too limiting (Wertsch, 1998). Suggesting an inter-disciplinary approach, however, requires
that we find ways to constructively connect divergent perspectives. We have successful examples of
this as theories of situated cognition have staked out a position which facilitates the integration of
aspects of cognitive science with anthropological and cultural traditions. Similarly in literary studies
there is an increasing interest in incorporating methods and theory from the cognitive sciences to
support new initiatives to investigate the literary system from empirical perspectives. In addition,
researchers in the field of measurement and evaluation have been proposing a more
inter-disciplinary theoretical framework to accommodate an elaborated view of validity in
educational assessment.
This paper examines the argument that drawing from multiple disciplinary traditions
provides additional contexts against which we can set traditional disciplinary practices and thereby
highlight the assumptions, values, and limitations of the different perspectives. The reported
research draws on theories of situated cognition and on literary theory to investigate the activity of
writing assessment. The central questions of the study are what accounts for valid assessment of
written essays, and how can what we know about valid literary interpretation inform our
investigation?
Six experienced and highly trained raters were divided into two groups of three raters each.
Each group collaboratively rated 20 essays from an English Language Proficiency Test. The rating
sessions were videotaped. The findings suggest that when the rating of essays is accomplished
through collaborative dialogue, debate, justification and explanation, the essentially interpretive
nature of that process is revealed. At the same time, the findings locate the interpretations not only
in the textual but in the contextual evidence as well and suggest that the inferred intentions of the
writer play a role in the decision-making process of experienced raters. Thus, the assessment of
writing appears to be a principled hermeneutic activity sharing characteristics with literary
interpretation.
Making Sense of Poetry and Making Sense of Art:
From Authorial Intention to Aesthetic Form
Joan Peskin
This paper explores poetry as textual art. It describes an expert-novice study on
understanding difficult period poetry and it then examines the appreciation of rhetorical form as
compared to the appreciation of aesthetic form. Rhetorical form concerns itself with an awareness
of the relationship between the writer and the intended audience. In most domains, the ability to take
factual statements as expressing audience directed intention only becomes evident in the graduate
years. However, in the present research on reading difficult period poetry, undergraduates and even
advanced high school students do not just interpret the content of the poem but have a concept of
interpretation. They ruminate over the poet's intentions, the unifying theme, and the difference
between what the poet said and what is meant. With regard to poetic discourse, there appears to be a
precocious awareness of the rhetorical form. The paper then explores artistic interpretation in the
visual arts and argues that poetry occupies a place somewhere between text and art. The reader of
poetic discourse also needs to be aware of aesthetic or artistic form, that is, how the components of
the poem effect and amplify the meaning. In the present study the Ph.D. students, but not the
undergraduates, show appreciation of aesthetic form. Furthermore, when meaning breaks down,
undergraduates use the general strategies from reading comprehension, whereas the Ph.D. students
move from trying to construct a representation of what the poem is saying to how the poet is saying
it. Finally, the study is related to expertise in other disciplines, such as history and mathematics, and
the educational implications are discussed.
On Hamming it Up: The Differences Between Poets'
and Actors' Recitations of Verse
Tom Barney
This paper follows on from the one I gave at the Utrecht IGEL conference in 1998 (Barney,
in press). There, I distinguished between those prosodic features of poetic recitation which belong
specifically to poetic recitation, and those which are features of vocal performance in general. In
this paper, I examine the differences between two contrasting types of poetic performance.
When we listen to poets reciting their own work, the impression is usually of a
straightforward speaking of the lines; but when we listen to actors reciting poetry we are likely to
encounter many more prosodic mannerisms, which can be obtrusive. I analyse prosodically both
poets' and actors' recitations, showing that the differences between them can be accounted for as
differences in the sound of vocal fold vibration or 'voice quality' (Laver 1980), in the unusual
placement and types of pitch accent in actors' recitations, and in the placement and length of
pauses.
I go on from this analysis to speculate on the reasons for these differences, arguing that
they represent different views of the nature of performance and its relation to the text. Poets, I
suggest, see a recitation as an oral version of the text, in which an attempt is made to negotiate
tensions between metre and form, on the one hand, and the language of a specific poem, on the
other, tensions which in print can be left to lie as ambiguities. Actors need to convey a sense of
having devised a performance that belongs to them personally, and do this by interposing an overlay
of non-verbal vocal features which is less directly related to the text.
32. Presidential Address
Emotion and Meaning in the Arts
Gerald C. Cupchik
Psychologists have generally treated emotion and cognition as if they were separate
phenomena. Some maintain that emotion happens so quickly that it does not need cognition, while
others argue that emotion is simply background noise which can disrupt proper cognition. I will
present a theory which holds that emotion and cognition are complementary and inextricably linked;
each is the ground to the other's figure. When cognition is central, emotion serves as a kind of
feeling that either energizes or disrupts depending on its level of intensity. When emotion is focal,
cognition provides a framework for understanding that draws upon collective and personal
experience, lending coherence to unfolding events in narratives, both real and fictional.The narrative
of my own empirical wanderings across a wide variety of cultural artefacts, ranging from sculptures
to scented short stories, and even magazine photographs, reveals feelings that underlie cognition and
emotions that support the "effort after meaning." I will discuss both the processes underlying this
complementary relationship and the role that an empirical approach can play in elucidating them.
33. Symposium
THE ADVERTISING SOCIETY
Siegfried J. Schmidt
Since the 18th century, four distinct macro-forms of communication have emerged which
still characterize the communication system of modern media-cultural societies: literature,
journalism, advertising, and Public Relations (PR). Whereas literary communication is dominated
by the difference fiction/non fiction, the journalism by the difference truth/untruth, and PR by the
difference trust/distrust, advertising seems to be determined not by referential relations but instead
by the difference consequential attention/inattentiveness.
From the very beginning of mass media assisted advertising, advertising activities formed
part of an economy of attention. By and through strategically planned and distributed media offers,
customers from all parts of society tried to attract as much attention as possible on goods, services,
messages or persons they wished to promote. Every new medium, from print to Internet, was
rapidly instrumentalized for advertising purposes; and since all media systems as social systems are
governed by economic principles in order to survive and to make money, step by step the
communication of and in media societies necessarily became commercialized. That is to say that
advertising has two kinds of effects: Structural ones as result of its interaction with other social
systems, and semantic ones resulting from the recipients activities triggered by media offers.
Although until now nobody knows exactly how advertising works research into ad effects
is extremely demanding due to the complexity of its subject domain - , no one who really intends to
make someone or something known, prominent, or bought can dispense with advertising. Firms and
politicians, churches and lobbies, political parties or soccer clubs: they all make use of advertising in
order to conquer and to preserve a position in the public sphere.
Advertising can be observed as an excellent observer of all those socio-cultural and
economic developments which are deemed relevant with regard to the mentality of the specific target
groups, because ads of any kind must be perfectly tuned to the respective essence of this mentality.
But of course, when we observe advertising as an indicator of social developments we have to take
into account that advertising is only interested in positive stories about its subjects. Advertising is
overtly biased and anybody knows that. Accordingly it tells stories which nobody holds to be
true. But why is advertising so efficient, so inevitable, and so impertinent?
Quite evidently people in modern societies need somebody who does not tell them what
there is and what they already know, but what might be and what is unheard of before it is before
the respective product, service etc. featured in the ad has been available. Thus, as J. Baudrillard once
said, advertising is the perfect blend of mother and Santa Claus.
Even this first glimpse at advertising reveals the great variety of promising perspectives on
this macro-form of communication. The section "Advertising Society" invites papers to all those
perspectives, from the history of advertising to its phenomenology, from the economic to the
political effects of advertising, from research in ad effects to reflections on the future of advertising.
Theoretical papers as well as reports on empirical projects are welcome, all media used for
advertising purposes may be analysed, production as well as distribution, reception or post
processing of ads can be thematized.
Advertising in Search of the Future(s)
Siegfried J. Schmidt
It is very unlikely to assume that a forecast of the future of advertising will come true in the
next future. Nevertheless advertising as well as advertising research need forecasts in terms of
operative fictions serving as tools for the observation of ongoing developments. Only via the
explicit deception of expectations can we learn and gain new categories for further distinctions.
Advertising needs self-produced future(s) in order to master the concomitant presence.
Advertising, i.e. the prototype of the well paid battle for consequential attention faces a
double paradox: (1) Attention as precondition for sale forces a self-induced sale of attention and (2)
The better ads generate attention via proliferating media offers, the more attention runs short. I
guess the future of the advertising system will be determined by the way these paradoxes are
handled.
It is likely to assume that advertising will make progressive use of the Internet without
reducing its presence in all other media. In addition, unconventional ad instruments will be
developed in order to reduce the overload of ads in the various media and to come closer to the
people in interactive surroundings rendering advertising a quasi-natural part of their lives.
Between Use and Abuse: Mediated Subcultures in Advertising
Christoph Jacke
In my paper I will argue that, on the one hand, advertising needs sub-cultural influences
(e.g. music, fashion) of different kinds (e.g. so called punk, grunge or techno) to coopt
andcolonize them whereas, on the other hand, new subcultures need something like the advertising
mainstream in order to make a difference. There is a lack of analyzing and theorizing about this
phenomenon in the social sciences. Subcultures are not non- or counter-cultures. They are cultures,
i.e. dynamic systems of differences. Therefore, they function more or less in the same ways and
through the same channels as the institutionalized parts of the culture industries. The subcultures
work via the same mediated offers of communication. Members of so called subcultures more and
more tend to use the same techniques of communication to produce media offers and to gain
attention. Having reached the market of attention, other institutions such as mainstream media and
especially the advertising industries and their trend-scouts pay attention to those underground
phenomena and (ab-)use them as strategic means and themes that help to achieve advertising aims.
Consequently, does it increasingly become normal to be abnormal?
More people spend more time watching, reading, listening, and using the media. It is
therefore likely that more sub-cultural alliances will develop in terms of their enthusiasm, represent
themselves via media offerings, and will be observed by the advertising industries. Underlined by an
empirical study, I will try to show how quickly sub-cultural phenomena find their way (i.e., are
adapted by the advertising industries) into commercial spots and whether or not there can be found
a kind of acceleration within this adaptation as media philosophers speak of the acceleration of
social changes within society and media.
Ads in disguise?
Sebastian Junger
Empirical research on and personal attitudes towards advertising are only possible because
we all hold certain views about what advertising is, ought to be or should not be. But besides
normative or non-normative scientific as well as everyday-definitions, there is a more fundamental
mechanism of recognizing advertisement: We know it as we perceive it. Considering advertising as
a macro-form of communication thus implies that we all have certain schemata of media use that
organize our perceptions of and interactions with media. These schemata, built up during the
media-socialization, form a distinct part of collective knowledge, a so called semantic disposition.
As far as advertising is concerned, the semantic disposition co-orients the attitudes, opinions, and
ways of behaviour we share, even before concrete contact with the ads. In this paper, I will try to
trace the constitution of the semantic disposition of ads for the traditional audiovisual media.
Further on, I will show how the new media, namely the internet and its specific forms of
communication, change this constitution by introducing different ways of perception and interaction
and new forms of advertising. The rather theoretical view on the changes of the semantic disposition
shall finally be exemplified by some empirical findings with concrete users.
Advertising Confidence
Guido Zurstiege
Above all, advertising is an absolutely practical activity it is thus, unfortunately, rather far
away from theory. Even though we are perfectly used to criticize its»affirmative rituals, we are still
relatively inexperienced in theorising advertising as a macro-form of communication such as e.g.
journalism, public relations or literature. In my paper, however, I will try to show that a non
normative theory of advertising can be used fruitfully to explain and to understand advertising as a
specific way of worldmaking. I will argue that the lack of confidence that we have in advertising
messages is one of the crucial points that help us to understand how advertising works. My
argument will evolve in three consecutive steps: I will open with a brief synopsis of the debates on
advertising focusing on the question of confidence. Despite the fact that in most of these debates
the lack of confidence in advertising-messages is considered to be a strong obstacle to the
effectiveness of advertising, I will argue that the lack of confidence can also be instrumentalized in a
most effective and creative way within the framework of advertising itself to produce consequential
attention. In a second step, I will attempt to outline some of the most prominent strategies that
construct respectively compensate confidence in advertising. Finally, I will examine several sample
advertisements that might add some empirical evidence to the general argument of my paper.
34. Symposium
EVOLUTIONARY APPROACHES TO LITERATURE: II
David Miall & Willie van Peer
The First Poetry? The Stylistics of Babytalk
David S. Miall
The incentive to respond to poetic features of language may occur as early as the first few
weeks of life. In this paper (prepared in part with the help of Ellen Dissanayake) I examine the
nature of the mother-infant interaction commonly called "babytalk" and suggest that its stylistic
features contain the precursor of later aesthetic response. Babytalk is spontaneously generated by
mothers, using temporally-organized behaviors (special infant-directed vocalizations, facial
expressions and gestures) to engage their pre-verbal infants' attention and to regulate their
emotional state. For their part, pre-verbal infants appear to be innately ready to prefer and respond
to these features. The mother's speech exhibits a systematic use of metrical stresses and other
rhythmic features, and phonetic variations and contrasts, to facilitate the mutual regulation of
affective and perceptual interaction.
In literary language such rhythmic and phonetic features are considered "aesthetic" and can
be analyzed for "poetic diction." I consider how far the mother's speech patterns offer a prototype
of such diction, serving to create an aural texture that enables foregrounding of features and
coherence at several different levels, and I suggest how the infant's reception might anticipate and
prepare for later poetic response. In a wider sense, the significance of babytalk can be seen within
an evolutionary perspective that points to the power of the arts to dehabituate and retune cognitive
and affective processes.
Hero and Villain as Human Universals
Ian Jobling
The account of a universal, biologically rooted human nature given by evolutionary
psychologists enables us both to describe the figures of hero and villain in world narrative better
than has been done before and also to explain why people universally tell narratives with heroes and
villains in them. Evolutionary psychologists argue that human ethics is rooted in a relationship of
cooperation or reciprocal altruism in which two or more humans perform actions which are costly
to themselves and beneficial to others in the expectation that benefit will be reciprocated. Human
morality and immorality are, in part, defined by this cooperative relationship. One is moral if one
participates in cooperative relations with others. One is immoral if one violates the cooperative
relationship either by refusing to cooperate with others or by taking something from someone for
one's own benefit and not giving anything back, e.g., by stealing something from someone, by
taking someone's life, or by cheating someone. Furthermore, Alexander and others have argued that
we evolved to overestimate the extent of our altruism and strength: as Robert Trivers says, we
overestimate our "beneffectance".
These insights from Darwinian ethics enable us to describe and account for a narrative one
finds universally -- my examples are the African Epic of Sundiata, the medieval French Song of
Roland, and the North American Native story Blood-Clot-Boy. In this narrative, a villain commits a
violation of the cooperative relationship against someone, either by refusing to cooperate with that
person or by committing an act of aggression or cheating against him. The villain is then punished
by a hero who is supernaturally strong and who represents a moral ideal. We tell this story because
it reinforces the illusions about ourselves that evolutionary psychologists have described: the hero
presents an ideal image of the self as altruistic and strong with which we identify.
The Negotiation of Scenarios in Five Novels of Female Development
Joseph Carroll
A relatively naive form of sociobiological literary criticism consists in examining fictional
texts and pointing out that the characters follow certain basic patterns of behavior in areas such as
survival, status seeking, mate selection, reproduction, parent-child interaction, and nepotism.
Psychologically more sophisticated interpretive efforts have extended this list to include other topics
in mainstream psychology such as the theory of emotions, development, and individual differences
in personality. The most advanced form of sociobiological criticism integrates the analysis of
represented behavior with the analysis of specifically literary structures such as verse forms, the
organization of narrative, tonal organization, the use of symbolic motifs, and the manipulation of
point of view. I shall argue that this latter category point of view--has a special status. Literary
representations are communicative acts, and meaning is always meaning for some specific person,
from some specific point of view. Drawing on Anatonio Damasio and E. O. Wilson, I shall
designate literary representations as "scenarios" or interpretive models of reality, and I shall argue
that literary meaning emerges out of the interaction from among three sets of scenarios: the author's
own (generally privileged) version of truth and reality; the versions formulated by the characters
depicted, and the version implicitly attributed to the putative audience. The author negotiates with
the divergent and often conflicting meaning systems of his characters, and he or she negotiates
simultaneously with the expectations, values, sympathies, and antipathies of his or her putative
readers. To illustrate these claims, I shall be comparing five novels that depict the personal
development of young women: Austen's Pride and Prejudice, Bronte's Villette, Cather's O Pioneers!,
Bennet's Anna of the Five Towns, and Hardy's Tess of the d'Urvbervilles. These novels have been
chosen to illustrate specific differences in the authors' relations to their subject.
Narrative and Natural Selection: Where Stories Come from and Why
Michelle Scalise Sugiyama
Storytelling is likely to have emerged at least 30,000 years ago. Yet the study of how and
why the mind generates narrative has not been conceptualized in terms of human evolutionary
history and the ancestral problem(s) to which storytelling may be a response. Cognitive
psychologists have long sought to understand narrative design-i.e., the rules by means of which it is
assembled--but the resultant models (known as story grammars) have been developed without
consideration of narrative function. At the other end of the spectrum, literary scholars offer
numerous hypotheses regarding the function of narrative, but their premises are uninformed by an
understanding of cognitive design-i.e., the conditions under which the mind evolved and the tasks it
was designed to perform. I propose that narrative functions as a virtual reality: by simulating the
environment, it enabled our ancestors to acquire information useful to survival and reproduction
without undertaking the costs and risks of first-hand experience. One class of knowledge obviously
integral to our Pleistocene ancestors' survival was subsistence information. Interestingly, the oral
traditions of modern hunter-gatherers (whose living conditions approximate those of the
Pleistocene) contain significant quantities of foraging and related information. In this paper, then, I
(1) sketch the conditions under which storytelling evolved; (2) demonstrate how various literary
devices (e.g., setting, description, mimicry, anthropomorphism) can be used to transmit subsistence
information; and (3) present quantitative evidence from a survey of several hunter-gatherer groups
that narrative is commonly used to exchange this information.
35. Paper Session
THE WRITING PROCESS: II
How Novices Become Poets: A Study of First-Time Poets in the
Swedish Literary Field of the 1970's
Daan Vandenhaute
In my paper, I want to report some of the results of my research on the literary careers of
first-time poets in the Swedish literary field of the 1970s. The starting point for this study is that
literature comes into being through the social interplay of several actors (authors, critics, editors
etc.) who, equipped with different forms and amounts of capital, are involved in a mutual struggle
over what actually is (valuable) literature. This study combines the research traditions of
institutional literary sociology (cfr. e.g. van Rees, 1983; Verdaasdonk, 1983; van Rees & Vermunt,
1996; Janssen, 1998) and of Bourdieuan cultural sociology. Undoubtedly, institutional sociology
has made vital contributions to our understanding of the functioning of the literary field. However,
through selfimposed restrictions in the research design, in which social backgroud or symbolic
practices are hardly accounted for, it does not always do justice to the complexity of this field.
I try to meet these objections by investigating not only institutional factors but also the
social background of the first-time poets as well as the symbolic space in which they took
positions. Therefore, for all first-time poets between 1968 and 1976 (except for those published at
their own expense or by distinctly regional or religious publishing houses; 106 in toto) data is
collected regarding publication strategies, sideline activities, institutional recognition as well as
preferences, artistic choices, symbolic position-takings, social background and educational level.
These data were obtained in different ways, through mail questionnaires, excerption of polemic
articles, manifestos and interviews, bibliometric study, and content analysis of the reviews the
authors received until 1981, and were analysed by means of correspondence analysis, allowing for
an assumption-free investigation of the relations between all elements determining the course of
their literary careers.
Poet's Person and Poet's Creativity
V.Koshkin, E. Kuzmina & E. Bazhenova
Do they coincide or is creativity something complementary to the real spirit and life
manifestations of a creator? An empirical investigation had been done to solve this problem. The
method includes the expert estimations of verses, the self-estimations of poets by the same polar
scales proposed, as well as the comparison with memoirs on the poets who had died before
researchers began their empirical investigation. Two canonized (A. Pushkin and T. Shevchenko)
and two contemporary (O. Zabuzhko and E. Bershin) poets of Russia and the Ukraine were the
subjects of this analysis. Twenty-three ten point scales were used by experts to evaluate each of
650, 250, 110 and 49 of their poems, respectively. Every expert also gave heuristic estimations of
the poets' psychology using the same scales. Both methods showed the same results. These are
the main conclusions:
1. The statistical psychological portraits of meanings for canonized poets seems to be in
agreement with memoirs of their friends. It was shown at the same time, that a frequency strength
of manifestations in a poetry does not coincide with claims of biographers. Very rare manifestations
had been interpreted as determining ones. Maybe quantitative analysis can give a criterion for
understanding what is important in creator's psyche.
2. Self portraits of two contemporary poets using the same 23 scales coincide with psychological
portraits obtained from the expert estimations of each of poem. This result demonstrates that the
poetry is the exact reflection of self-cognition of a poet. Are self-cognition and life manifestations
the same? That is a question, and we hope to provide an answer at the congress.
Male and Female Writers and Their Sideline Activities in the Literary Field
Lenny Vos
I would like to present a paper about the careers of postwar Dutch literary writers. As a Ph.
D. student, I studied the postwar Dutch literary field and the participation of female writers within
this field. It appears that writers who are active on several fronts receive more attention of literary
critics than the ones who only publish new literary work. Authors who engage in sideline activities
increase the amount of relations they have in the literary field; their so-called social capital. Critics
can also place them in a literary movement. By writing poetical articles and giving interviews,
authors are able to change opinions about their literary work.
I have been collecting data of both male and female writers who have published prose and/or
poetry in the postwar Dutch literary field. I choose to collect data of five years; 1947, 1957, 1967,
1977, and 1987. A part of these authors were selected at random and their sideline activities were
collected. Sideline activities include the publication of prose or poetry in literary magazines, critical
writing for newspapers and (literary) magazines, membership of a literary movement or other
poetical activities like publishing work in a compilation. Also, more organizational activities, like an
editorship of a literary magazine or membership of a jury for awarding literary prizes, are included
to give an overview of activities in the literary field. The research will focus on the assumption that
female writers engage less in activities in the literary field than do their male contemporaries. It is
also possible to compare different generations of writers within the postwar Dutch literary field and
their number of literary activities.
Reporting War: A Test for Journalists
Kingsley Ivan Evans
The resurgence of violence in the country has once again put Sierra Leone in the news and
for the general populace, it has put them to another round of misery. As events unfold in the
country, journalists, are expected to accurately inform the public about the war. But do people love
to hear the truth about the war? Who will cry when a journalist is killed at the war front? The bullet
does not discriminate or ask the journalist questions before sending him to his grave. No, it doesn't.
Yet the journalist is expected to carry out his duties. Journalists are expected to feed the public with
latest developments at the war front. But you would agree with me that war reporting could be an
extremely risky business.
Sierra Leone's civil war in particular is known to have claimed the lives of quite a number of
journalists. These days, nobody or perhaps only few people think about those journalists who have
died in the process of trying to accurately inform their listeners or readers. At a recent peaceful
demonstration, one journalist, Saoman Conteh, was gunned down. Another, Edward Kamara of the
SLBS TV sustained gun-shot wounds. Many others narrowly escaped death.
In reporting the war this time round, I would like to admonish journalists to be very careful.
They should know that a dead correspondent is a bad correspondent. In fact, I am yet to see a news
agency that would be more interested in a news story than the life of its correspondent. Be on your
guard. There is something about war reporting once you start reporting you are tempted to continue
and continue and continue. Reporting the war (or fighting?) around Freetown, as it is, is not as
difficult as doing the same from the provinces in terms of communication facilities. Until the war
situation turned upside down, the news about the war was localized in the provinces, especially the
East. You can imagine the frustration in having a well-prepared report which is virtually useless
because there is no way to pass it over for public consumption.
To my colleagues, I say, don't ever go to the front line if you have no means of dispatching
your reports. It is as good as doing nothing. When you go into war reporting, make sure you are
sent there by some organization. Never go there just in the name of bravery. Even for a freelance
journalist, never go to report a war without any news agency knowing what you are doing. Being a
war journalist may be a fashionable title but once you've set out to the front your sense of judgment
must be sharp, in fact sharper. When you live to report, you must have it at the back of your mind
that your are a journalist, not a soldier. Your have no business with guns but with pens and
microphones. Try to be neutral as best as possible. In war, there is an aphorism that truth is the first
causality. The question as to whether to tell the whole truth as you see it, begs for answer. If you tell
the truth about your nation's weaknesses or losing a battle, you step on the toes of most people
including, of course, the government.
36. Paper Session
SCIENTIFIC STUDIES OF RECEPTION AND INTERACTIVITY
Once Is Not Enough: Statistical Simulation of Textual Data
Robert Hogenraad
Reproduction is part of the regulations of daily speech. Everyday experience shows that
there are different ways to convey the same information: Starting sentences that we quickly rephrase
using other words, manuscripts passing through draft states before the writer decides upon the final
version. In more ways than one, thus, any text is always but the sample of another one and the
words we read are but the visible part of an iceberg.
James Joyce's Ulysses was content analyzed using the Regressive Imagery Dictionary.
Among other things, this dictionary allows one to assess the degree of presence, in texts, of
primordial thought content (love, sex, food, chaos, dream, flying, for example). A negative linear
profile was observed, i.e., primordial content decreases as the one-day journey goes by.
Pondering this negative linear profile makes one wonder about the enterprise of statistical
analysis, how little it tells us, how brittle is a quantitative analysis of a literary work in the face of the
uncertainty that surrounds such data. New ways to look at literary data consist of re-sampling
thousands of time data that by nature exist in only one exemplar, bringing empirical study of
literature down to what literature is made of, inking out, excisions, alterations, disappearances. The
rates of primordial thought content were repeated 2,000 times, using a bootstrap algorithm.
The best contribution one can make to empirical studies of literature is not to collect more
p< something that doesn't prove a thing, but to hammer scholars in order to see how well re
sampling allows one to assess the degree of uncertainty associated with any measurement. Until
now, there is no indication that empirical studies of literature so much as noticed the difference that
has taken place in processing textual data by a systematic exploration of uncertainty.
The Uses and Gratifications of Game Platform and Computer Role-Playing Games
Kenneth D. Day, Marlin Bates IV, & Qingwen Dong
This study examines the uses and gratifications that game platform and computer
role-playing games serve for their audiences and looks at examples of this form of entertainment as
texts of varying openness and varying social interaction. Of all the genres of video games, the game
platform role-playing game is the best exemplar of a narrative form. Stories often display
considerable complexity and in some games, such as the recent Star Ocean, a number of different
endings may be arrived at by the choices made in response to the unfolding story. Recently, a
number of on-line role-playing games (The Realm, Ultima On-Line, Everquest, Asheron's Call)
have emerged, which allow players to interact with a community of players around the world. While
players acquire skills and engage in combat with monsters as in the conventional game platform
role-playing game, these games have little structure and as such are experienced as open texts that
the player largely writes in interaction with other players. These games also, to varying degrees,
offer a game world in which players can acquire property and build relationships with other players.
Indeed, Origin, Inc., the manufacturer of Ultima Online has acknowledged in its recent press
releases that the company has come to the realization that it is not producing games but rather
virtual worlds. This study examines the uses and gratifications of both types of games through a
large sample survey of players of game platform role-playing games in general and a second large
sample survey specifically of the players of Ultima On-Line. Uses and gratifications are shown to
differ for the two types of role-playing games. The importance of different uses and gratifications is
shown to vary systematically by age and gender and uses and gratifications sought are shown to
relate to personality variables and degree of social isolation.
Facilitating Scientific Text Reception Through Recognition of the Author
Ute Ritterfeld
An experiment was conducted to investigate the impact of biographical or photographic
information about the author (social information) on reading scientific texts in a foreign language.
It was assumed that this information could potentially affect preference and understanding of the
text. When students read scientific texts in a foreign language either they can examine the surface
or explore in greater depth. For students reading in a superficial manner, sympathy for the author
can spontaneously generalize to a preference for the text. Alternatively, knowledge about the author
might lead a reader to establish a more profound relationship toward the text. This could be
reflected in more systematic text processing and/or greater tolerance toward difficulties in text
comprehension. Subjects were two classes of German undergraduate students taking a course in the
reading of scientific articles written in English. One class, the experimental group, received
biographical information about the authors prior to reading the texts. A comparison of the two
groups revealed that receiving prior information about the author led to greater tolerance of
difficulties in text comprehension.
Empirical Studies of the Affect of the Theatrical Performance on the
Juvenile Audience in Soviet Russia
Yulia Landa
The presentation will include a brief analysis of the political, ideological and cultural situation
in Soviet Russia that contributed to the development of it's own unique approach to the theory and
research on people's perception of art, and influence of art, theater, and literature on personality
development. More attention will be given to the studies of a theatrical audience conducted in the
Soviet Union since 1919. The majority of those studies were performed in the St.Petersburg
(formerly Leningrad) Theater for Young Spectators (TUZ). The St.Petersburg Theater for Young
Spectators was open in 1922 with a special mission to facilitate children and adolescents emotional,
intellectual, and esthetic growth by making them active participants in the theatrical performances.
Therefore, empirical studies of the spectators' reactions became an important part of the theater's
activity. I will describe empirical studies conducted at the theater during different time periods, as
well as my own research performed in 1989 -1991. During this period, the St. Petersburg Theater
for Young Spectators produced 7 new plays written by Soviet, European, and American playwrights
(there were no classical Russian plays produced at that time). The affect of all of the plays on the
audience was studied empirically. Spectators' reactions were studied in correlation with
socio-demographic (age, gender, place of residence, educational level, level of familiarity with a
theater as a form of art) and psychological (general level of emotional-intellectual development,
personality traits, and mood just prior the performance) factors. Spectators' emotional reactions;
degree of emotional involvement; degree of empathizing with the characters; perception of the
characters' personal qualities; level of understanding of the plot, relationships between characters,
overall meaning; the subjective importance of the play's meaning; and other factors were studied.
Questionnaires, psychological tests, interviews, drawings, compositions, and group discussions
were used for data collection. I will discuss strengths and weaknesses of these studies and describe
some of the findings as well as their practical and theoretical implications.
37. Symposium
LITERARY CENSORSHIP
Achim Barsch
Literary Censorship And the Empirical Study of Literature
Achim Barsch
From a systems theoretical point of view, the paper will give a definition of literary
censorship and will deal with the history, reasons and mechanisms of censorship in general. The
objective of the paper will be the literary system and those relations to other social systems that lead
to social conflicts concerning literature. I will argue that social conflicts about literary texts are part
of the normal evolution of the literary system. Therefore they should not be blamed in advance.
However, social conflicts about literary texts have not always had to be settled by the judicial
system. Interventions into the literary system trying to control it depending on the social, cultural,
and political background will be discussed as forms of literary censorship. Some historical and
current examples will be analyzed.
Between Freedom of the Media and Intrusions of Censorship: An Examination of Media
and Law Sociological Research on the Influence of Censorship on the Popular Culture of
the Federal Republic of Germany
Roland Seim
This study, which focuses mainly on examples from the media in the Federal Republic of
Germany, examines the reasons for censorship and the structure that such intrusions on the free
speech can take. The thesis of the art-historian (M.A.) and sociologist (Ph.D.) Roland Seim
consists of two main parts: The first lays down the historical-theoretical framework and examines
the conditions of censorship on the basis of their legal foundations. This preoccupation of his
research includes a summary of the history of censorship which will lead up to the position of post
war West Germany and a description of the role and function of the main institutions which
executes censorship. The second part consists of a descriptive-empirical analysis and highlights
such intrusions into free speech by pointing to significant examples from diverse genres as
literature, film, music, art, comic, satire and new media. The aim to restrict the publication and
distribution of material on the internet especially demonstrates the desire of government to control
its contends. The state tries to gain influence against unwanted expressions. A lot of different forms
of censorship (mainly in Germany) will be explored. This work contains additional digressions
into matters of political censorship and the fascination of banned material. Questions of how to
undermine such interest into prohibited areas are raised and the author establishes the immense
difficulties of governing bodies in judging between what can be tolerated and what is to be banned.
He also demonstrates how the boundaries of the permissible are in a constant state of change and
aims to demonstrate the different (and often subtle) forms of govern-mental, religious and social
censorship. The right of free expression, however, can clash with human dignity. The examples of
child pornography and fascistic propaganda should indicate the problematic demand for the total
abolition of censorship. The thesis concludes with a comparative examination of some censorship
laws in various European Countries and the United States. This international comparison
demonstrates, that the loss of a sense of humour on matters of taste, decency and hallowed icons is
not only a German phenomenon. ¿
La censure: Le régime franquiste et les auteurs français.
(Censorship: Franco's regime and French writers)
Ebtehal Younes
Dans tout régime totalitaire, la censure sur les écrits est une arme capitale pour le contrôle de
la société, et un moyen de propagande des idées du régime. Pour le régime franquiste (1939-1975),
tous les livres devaient être au service des idées de la nouvelle Espagne. Avant même la victoire
définitive et l'instauration du régime franquiste, une Loi de la Presse, promulguée en 1938 en pleine
guerre civile, confiait au Service National de Propagande la tâche de censure des livres. En 1942, le
régime créa le Vice-Secrétariat d'Education Populaire dont une des tâches principales était de
réviser toute la littérature espagnole imprimée et son adaptation aux nouvelles circonstances. Ce
Vice-Secrétariat avait également pour tâche celle de contrôler l'importation de livres de l'étranger et
de surveiller les traductions de la littérature étrangère, dans le but d'éviter toute dissonnance entre
cette littérature venue de l'extérieur et l'idéologie du régime. En 1952, ce Vice-Secrétariat disparaît,
à la suite de la création du Ministère de l'Information et du Tourisme, désormais chargé de la
censure jusqu'à la fin du régime. Ces trois étapes dans l'exercice de la censure dénotent l'évolution
des rapports de force entre les différentes fractions (Phalange et Eglise, en particulier) dans leur
lutte pour la main-mise sur le pouvoir sous le franquisme.
Dans cette littérature étrangère soumise à la censure, la littérature française occupe une place
importante, et ceci pour plusieurs raisons: la proximité géographique et le voisinage, la francophonie
traditionnelle des intellectuels espagnols, ou le rôle, positif ou négatif, souvent joué par la France
dans l'histoire de l'Espagne; cette France souvent considérée, sous le franquisme, comme source de
tous les maux.
Notre travail se propose d'étudier la censure exercée par le régime franquiste sur les écrits
des auteurs français, à travers l'étude des dossiers de la censure officielle de l'Etat ainsi que la
censure officieuse, c'est-à-dire ecclésiastique. Cette censure sur les oeuvres françaises a commencé
dès le lendemain de la chute de Madrid, le 30 mars 1939, aux mains de Franco, quand le journal
officiel du régime (Hoja de Burgos) publie une liste d'écrivains français considérés comme
"ennemis" par le régime franquiste. Nous avons choisi un échantillon formé de seize écrivains
français: onze appartenant au XX siècle, et cinq appartenant au XIX siècle. Car cette censure ne
s'exerçait pas seulement sur les écrits nouveaux, mais également sur la ré-édition d'écrits déjà
publiés et édités auparavant.
Notre travail se propose donc un double but. D'une part, ce que révèle et dénote les dossiers
de censure sur l'évolution interne du régime franquiste au long de ses quarante ans d'existence, à
travers l'évolution des critères et des décisions de censure. D'autre part, ces dossiers de censure
permettent de constater et de déduire quelle image de la France et quelle version de la littérature
française étaient officiellement permises en Espagne franquiste, et quelles autres étaient interdites.
Egypt's Intellectual Crisis: Religious Censorship
on Literature and Academic Research
Nasr Abu Zayd
Since the introduction of the print technology, which was first brought to Egypt by the
French expedition (1798-1801), the age of the printed culture started to gradually emerge. It was
primarily brought to enable Napoleon to print and distribute, first, his political propaganda to
convince the Egyptian elite of his good intentions and then was used to print his 'orders' to be
obeyed and his 'regulations' to be followed as the leader and ruler of Egypt. It is believed that this
expedition disrupted the old societal order and paved the way for a new order. It was during the era
of Mohammed Ali (1805-1841) that the modern state of Egypt started to replace the old traditional
society. One of the most important aspects of that process of modernization was the establishment
of the first Egyptian official newspaper, for which the first print was imported. It was during the
reign of Khedive Ishmael (1863-1879), who wanted Egypt to be part of the European Culture, that
the age of the press, the major factor in creating the public opinion, started. The age of press
demanded the introduction of the first 'law of censorship on printed matters'. The essential target
of the law was to 'protect,' among other things, the official religion of the state, Islam, against any
blasphemy.
This first official law had to be amended several times to cooperate wiith the political and
social development of the country. This paper intends to primarily investigate some of the major
incidents in which books were not only banned but also the writers of these books were severely
punished. The paper aims at analyzing the socio-political context of each of these incidents to
convey the relationship between the Egyptian State and religion. The religious Islamic sentiment
aroused by the abolishment of the Caliphate in Turkey in 1924, which ended the long established
political system of the Ottoman Empire, created an atmosphere of political insecurity among
Muslims. This atmosphere created a very strong reactionary movement in Egypt that led to the
establishment of the Muslim Brothers Society in 1928. The impact of this society, which developed
into a semi-unofficial political party that is still very active today, is to be taken into consideration.
Another major factor to be considered is the conflict relationship between the well-established old
Islamic educational institution, al-Azhar, and the relatively modern established secular university
founded in 1908. The essential censored material to be dealt with will be academic as well as non
academic research publications. It will also include, as a secondary material, some literary
production such as novels, poetry, plays and short stories. The period to be covered is the twentieth
century.
38. Paper Session
CRITICAL ANALYSIS IN LITERARY RECEPTION
Empiricism and the Study of Language
- David Bleich
Philosophical empiricism teaches that only experiments with phenomena can yield
understanding because anyone can repeat the experiments that lead to agreement and not just
consensus. Most procedures we take as "empirical" demand repeatable experiments.
The study of language and literature resists this procedure. Relative to the slow changes of
cosmic, chemical, or biological phenomena (all of which do change over time), changes in language
and literature are rapid, changing their ways at rates perceptible within human lifetimes. Repeatable
experiments are therefore not possible, as a rule. Yet these subjects and their dependence on the
shape and history of society are as material as the subjects traditionally studied by empirical
techniques.
In this century, from the later work of Wittgenstein, disciplined ways of doing empirical
investigations of language and literature have emerged. His categories, "language games," "forms of
life," and "family resemblance," are distinctive because they enable explanations of language that
accommodate the way language use continuously changes.
A Problem About Literary Knowledge
Carol Gould
Aeschylus' Oresteia portrays the universe as rationally ordered, with gods and men
achieving nobility and justice. Euripides' Bacchae, in contrast, presents an opposing vision, with
irrationality governing the human self and the gods, and passion threatening the polis. Both of
these literary works are equally seductive in drawing us into their fictional worlds and equally
interesting as purely artistic entities. Yet the views they make persuasive to us are logically
inconsistent. How can we adjudicate between these views without inspecting the world outside of
each literary work?
This, as Jerome Stolnitz has argued, presents a problem for the cognitivist about literature,
that is, one who believes that a work of art can reveal something to us about the world by engaging
our imaginative faculties. Imagination, according to the cognitivist, can be a source of knowledge,
and so literature can teach us, particularly about the human condition. This view is intuitively
appealing, especially for those who enjoy literature and take interest in its history and formal
properties. But the inconsistency of literary works does force us to question how we can discover
that a proposition is true without experience of the world. It seems implausible that imaginative
engagement with a non-actual world could teach us something about the actual world.
In this paper, I offer a modest version of cognitivism that can accommodate the
inconsistency problem. To forge a link between a fictional world and the actual one. I propose a
model of imaginative knowledge in aesthetic experience that is analogous to (but not a kind of) a
priori or deductive forms of understanding. By implying an organic notion of the literary work, this
model will point us toward a solution to a further problem for cognitivism, namely, whether any
cognitive meaning a literary work would contribute to the work's aesthetic or literary value.
Reading the Rocks, Reading the Reading:
Doing "Science" andUnderstanding the Contexts of Texts
Russell A. Hunt
Surely there's no science whose data are harder than geology Yet, consider John McPhee's
brilliant four-volume treatment of one of the major scientific revolutions of the last century: the
process through which one set of explanations for those data -- rocks whose composition no one
could question -- were supplanted by a quite radically different set of explanations of the same
rocks: "plate tectonics." What McPhee makes clear, among other things, is that the stories people
tell about the data vary enormously.
The comparison between the empirical data of geology and those of empirical studies of
literature clearly is a strained one, since the character - - or even the existence -- of literary "data"
has been questioned from the beginning. It seems reasonable to question whether a poem is "there"
in the sense that a piece of granite is there; it seems sensible to ask whether a metaphor isn't
"constituted" by a reader in a way that no one would seriously argue -- at least not to a geologist --
that a chunk of feldspar is.
In this presentation I will attempt to draw this comparison out to show that there are data in
literary studies equivalent to the rocks of the geologists, and that it's possible to imagine a process
by which a field might come to the kind of dramatic new consensus that geology has come to, by
looking at some examples of how different stories need to be told about our data, as about the data
of the geologist, according to our deepening understanding of the context of the data. It make a
difference what situation you find a text in, in exactly the same way as it makes a difference what
context you find a piece of gabbro in -- and the situation is constructed by the story you tell about
it.
Using examples from student and other readings of literary texts in differently constructed
contexts, I'll try to demonstrate how radical this difference can be, what dramatic effects it can have
on your perception of the data and the stories you tell about them. If I don't introduce an equivalent
of plate tectonics, I'll at least suggest that we may well be currently working in an exhausted
paradigm.
Three Ways of Knowing Literariness
Thomas J. Roberts
Literariness is what the things we call literature have in common. I point out that the tactics
of empirical inquiry into this literariness will vary as its focus shifts from one to another of the three
different ways experts have of learning whether anything is literature.
Those of us who teach literature and write about it may have learned that something is
literature by vicarious identification, for instance. Our own teachers told us it was literature, or a
friend, or critics we trust. The social psychologist will be asking who does persuade us and what is
persuasive. Or we learned that something is literature through direct experience of the object,
through an exploratory identification. We encountered a text, say, and that text persuaded us that it
is literature. In this case, the psychologist searching out the formal characteristics of literariness
would look at the object rather than at talk about the object.
Most often, we readers knew what people were saying about the object even as we were
reading it. This is the communal identification. Scientists pursuing empirical inquiry into this third
identification would study the ways in which the formal features of the objects themselves-the texts,
say--interact in our minds with the formal features of the reports other readers are giving of those
objects.
It is important that scientists not become so impatient that they simplify a complex reality by
silently assuming that one reader's (or viewer's or listener's) perception is definitive for all others.
Scientists must not take short cuts if they want to understand what gets things accepted as literature.
We shall want to understand all three ways of experiencing literariness: the vicarious, the
exploratory, and the communal.
39. BUSINESS MEETING
Please join us to discuss the selection of a venue for IGEL2002. There are many other
things to talk about including the future direction of IGEL and its relations with other international
groups involved with literary and media studies. Your ideas and opinions are very much valued so
make them known. A comprehensive agenda will be announced at the meeting.
40. BANQUET/CRUISE
The cruise will take place on board the Wayward Princess from 8 until midnight on
Thursday, August 3rd. We will depart from Vic by bus at 7:15 and there will be bus service back to
Vic. There will be a cash bar on board the boat. The cost of the dinner cruise for those not
registered at IGEL2000 is $50.00 CDN paid in cash.
41. Invited Address
A CENTRIPETAL VIEW OF THE ARTS
Ellen Dissanayake
In the early days of the twenty-first century, humanistic studies -- like nations, social
groups, and individuals -- can fairly be characterized as having separated into small bailiwicks or
even warring constituencies. Knowledge is generally considered to be relative, socially
constructed, even solipsistic.
In 1998, the American evolutionary biologist, E. O. Wilson, introduced a term,
"consilience," to refer to his vision of a unified centripetal view that seeks to embrace the sciences,
social sciences, and humanities. As part of the consilient endeavor, I will sketch an exploratory
framework for understanding literature and the other arts ethologically as evolved aspects of human
psychobiology, which includes an innate predisposition to make the ordinary (utterance, material,
place, movement, sound, or idea) extraordinary.
While not denying specific and unique features of individual instances of particular arts, the
existence of universal aspects is a fundamental principle of a centripetal view. With particular regard
to the literary arts, for example, one would take as a starting point the assumption that they can be
understood as having developed from ancient oral precursors perhaps as early as tens of thousands
of years ago. Additionally, as a universal characteristic of the human species (i.e., present in every
known culture), literary art (like the other arts) can be shown to arise from recognizable and
common human motivations or needs; to address recognizable and common humanly-relevant
themes and to use recognizable and common humanly-relevant symbols. Through elaboration,
shaping, and other (aesthetic) devices, ordinary utterance is "made special" or "made strange."
Thus, despite interesting differences and historical changes, one would also expect demonstrable
formal, figurative, and tonal features to underlie the various literary products of different cultures.
This ethological view of art as an adaptive behaviour will be contrasted with earlier,
customary views (from theology, philosophical aesthetics, sociology, anthropology, psychoanalysis,
experimental and clinical psychology, and neuroscience) that consider art as essence, revelation,
object (or work), neurosis, or mental faculty. I will show how these views -- unlike the ethological
view -- are only partial, and cannot address with universal applicability really fundamental questions
such as why the arts are found in every human society, where they come from, what they are, and
why they are not only desirable but important. With particular emphasis on the literary arts,
implications of a centripetal, consilient, inclusive view of the arts will be suggested.
42. PLENARY SESSION ON THE FUTURE OF RECEPTION STUDIES
Gerald Cupchik
In this session, Siegfried Schmidt, founding president of IGEL, will join Art Graesser and
Keith Oatley for reflections about IGEL2000 and to discuss the future of the empirical study of
literature and media. They will each make brief statements. A discussion will then ensue with all
participants regarding the direction of research and of our society. Please join us to share your
thoughts and feelings.
CONGRESS OFFICIALLY ENDS
43. Post-Congress Event
VIRTUAL ENTERTAINMENT
at
PLAYDIUM TORONTO
126 John Street just south of Queen Street
2:30-4:15 pm
The Playdium corporation describes itself as "setting the standard for location-based
entertainment in Canada....with 54,000 square feet soaring over four levels, outfitted with unique
state-of-the-art themed attraction areas on four action-packed levels. Enter and immerse yourself in
sheer entertainment bliss."
Playdium basically represents a very high level of arcade experience with unending kinds of
video and virtual reality type games. Playdium is providing free entrance for one hour for roughly
50 IGEL participants who want to visit. At the end of this hour we will have a session with some of
their staff to discuss the interactive games experience. The trade-off is that they provide the
entertainment experience and we provide the intellectual reflection.
As there are a limited number of places, tickets will be given out to the first 50 IGELs who
apply.